~ November 1992 INTERNET MONTHLY REPORTS ------------------------ The purpose of these reports is to communicate to the Internet Research Group the accomplishments, milestones reached, or problems discovered by the participating organizations. This report is for Internet information purposes only, and is not to be quoted in other publications without permission from the submitter. Each organization is expected to submit a 1/2 page report on the first business day of the month describing the previous month's activities. These reports should be submitted via network mail to: Ann Westine Cooper (Cooper@ISI.EDU) NSF Regional reports - Corinne Carroll (ccarroll@NNSC.NSF.NET) Directory Services reports - Tom Tignor (TPT2@ISI.EDU) Requests to be added or deleted from the Internet Monthly report list should be sent to "imr-request@isi.edu". Details on obtaining the current IMR, or back issues, via FTP or EMAIL may be obtained by sending an EMAIL message to "rfc- info@ISI.EDU" with the message body "help: ways_to_get_imrs". For example: To: rfc-info@ISI.EDU Subject: getting imrs help: ways_to_get_imrs Cooper [Page 1] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTERNET ACTIVITIES BOARD IAB MESSAGE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 3 INTERNET ENGINEERING REPORTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 16 Internet Projects CIX (COMMERCIAL INTERNET EXCHANGE). . . . . . . . . . . . page 23 CONCERT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 24 ISI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 25 JVNCNET . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 27 LOS NETTOS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 28 NEARNET (NEW ENGLAND ACADEMIC AND RESEARCH NETWORK) . . . page 28 NNSC, UCAR/BOLT BERANEK and NEWMAN, INC., . . . . . . . . page 30 NORTHWESTNET . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 31 NSFNET/ANSNET BACKBONE ENGINEERING. . . . . . . . . . . . page 32 NSFNET/INFORMATION SERVICES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 46 PREPnet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 48 SDSC (SAN DIEGO SUPERCOMPUTER CENTER) . . . . . . . . . . page 49 UCL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 50 WISCNET . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 51 CALENDAR OF EVENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 52 Cooper [Page 2] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 IAB MESSAGE A. REORGANIZATION Following the MIT IETF meeting in July 1992, the POISED working group was chartered by the IESG to develop proposals for modification of the management structure of the IETF. Three weeks ago, POISED reported to the IETF meeting in Washington D.C. Many discussions during the meeting led to a concensus proposal that was presented to the Thursday evening "open IESG" plenary. Most of the people who have been participating in the POISED WG agreed to this proposal, at least in principle, and the Thursday plenary expressed approval. There are two major components to this proposal. (1) New Assignment of Responsibilities * Responsibility for approving Internet Standards progression will be devolved from the IAB to the IESG. The IESG will make the final decision on the progression of specification documents through the Internet standards track, following the procedures as defined in RFC-1310 or a future replacement. The IESG is preparing to increase its technical review capacity to take on this additional work. * The IAB will serve as an adjudication board, to which appeals may be made on actions of any kind, including IESG actions on the progression of Internet Standards. * The IAB will continue to serve the community with an increasingly strong focus on architectural and long-term planning. This may result in launching new initiatives in the IETF and/or IRTF. * The IAB will also review the charters for new IETF working groups. (2) New Selection Procedures * Each member of the IESG and IAB will have a two-year term; an incumbent may however be re-nominated when a term expires. Terms will be staggered so 50% expire each year. * Candidates for open IAB and IESG seats will be selected by a "nominating committee" composed of 7 people selected at random from a pool of people who have met certain criteria and have Cooper [Page 3] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 volunteered to be in the pool. These 7 will be assisted by three non-voting "advisory" members, one each from the IAB, the IESG, and the IRSG. The result will be a list of candidates, at least one for each open seat. Selection of members from this candidate list will be performed by the ISOC trustees in the case of IAB members, and by the IAB in the case of IESG members. The IAB and IESG support these changes and are prepared to institute them as quickly and smoothly as possible. Half of the members of both boards will vacate their seats, to allow completion of the transition by the March 1993 IETF meeting. However, before they can be implemented, many details must be worked out, and the Board of Trustees of the Internet Society must approve the resulting change in the charter under which the IAB operates. The question will be presented to them on December 10. In anticipation of the changes, standards approvals have now been devolved to the IESG. B. SUMMARY OF STANDARDS TRACK The following table summarizes the Internet standards track as of December 4, 1992. The first segment of the table shows the specifications that have reached Internet Standard status since September 1, 1991. The following two segments respectively list all Draft Standard and Proposed Standard status specifications. Within each segment, entries are ordered by increasing date of last action, and within the same month, by increasing RFC number. Those dates prefixed with "*" give the approval date; however, the date of RFC publication determines the effective date of the action for determining time-in-grade. Cooper [Page 4] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== | |Proposed| Draft |Internet| | | | Description |Standard|Standard|Standard| RFC | RFC Title | | | Date | Date | Date | | | |======================================================================| |STD 34: RIP -- | Dec 88 | Apr 90 | Jul 92 | 1058 |Routing Information| | Routing | | | | |Protocol | | Information | | | | | | | Protocol | | | | | | ======================================================================== |STD 33: TFTP -- | Dec 88 | Oct 89 | Jul 92 | 1350 |The TFTP Protocol | | Trivial File | | | | |(Revision 2) | | Transfer | | | | |(STD 33) | | Protocol | | | | | | ======================================================================== |STD 35: | May 87 | Apr 90 | Aug 92 | 1006 |ISO Transport on | | ISO Transport | | | | |the TCP | | on the TCP | | | | | | ======================================================================== |STD 16+: | Feb 91 | Aug 91 | Oct 92 | 1212 |Concise MIB | |Concise MIB | | | | |Definitions | |Definitions | | | | | | ======================================================================= |STD ??: | Jun 89 | Sep 90 |* Dec 92| in |A Proposed Standard| |IP and ARP | | | | prep |for the Transmiss- | |over FDDI | | | | |of IP Datagrams | | | | | | |over FDDI Networks | ======================================================================= //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ======================================================================== |BOOTP | | Dec 88 | | 951 |Bootstrap Protocol | | | | | | |(BOOTP) | | | | | |==========================| | | | | | 1084 |BOOTP Vendor | | | | | | |Information | | | | | | |Extensions | ======================================================================== |NICNAME -- WhoIs| Oct 89 | Apr 90 | | 954 |NICNAME/WHOIS | |Protocol | | | | | | ======================================================================== |PPP | Nov 89 | May 90 | | 1171 |The Point-to-Point | | | | | | |Protocol for the | | | | | | |Transmission of | | | | | | |Multi-Protocol | | | | | | |Datagrams over | | | | | | |Point-to-Point | | | | | | |Links | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 5] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== |CMOT | Apr 89 | Sep 90 | | 1189 |The Common | | | | | | |Management | | | | | | |Information | | | | | | |Services and | | | | | | |Protocols for the | | | | | | |Internet (CMOT and | | | | | | |CMIP) | ======================================================================== |Telnet Linemode | Aug 89 | Oct 90 | | 1184 |Telnet Linemode | |Option | | | | |Option | ======================================================================== |Finger | Jun 90 | Nov 90 | | 1288 |The Finger User | | | | | | |Information | | | | | | |Protocol | ======================================================================== |POP3 | Nov 88 | Apr 91 | | 1225 |Post | | | | | | |Office Protocol - | | | | | | |Version 3 | ======================================================================== |OSPF -- Open | Apr 90 | May 91 | | 1247 |OSPF Version 2 | |Shortest-Path- | | | | | | |First routing | | | | | | |protocol | | | | | | ======================================================================= |BGP -- | Jun 90 | Oct 91 | | 1257 |A Border Gateway | |Border Gateway | | | | |Protocol (BGP-3) | |Protocol | | | |==========================| | | | | | 1268 |Application of the | | | | | | |Border Gateway | | | | | | |Protocol in the | | | | | | |Internet | ======================================================================== |IP over SMDS | Feb 91 | Mar 92 | | 1209 |Transmission of IP | | | | | | |Datagrams over the | | | | | | |SMDS Service | ======================================================================== |Ethernet MIB | Nov 91 | Oct 92 | | in |Definitions of | | | | | | prep |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |the Ethernet-like | | | | | | |Interface Types | ======================================================================== //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ======================================================================== |ISO-TS-ECHO -- | Jan 90 | | | 1139 |An Echo Function | |Echo Function | | | | |for ISO 8473 | |for ISO 8473 | | | | | | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 6] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== |TCP/IP Header | Mar 90 | | | 1144 |Compressing TCP/IP | |Compression | | | | |Headers for | | | | | | |Low-Speed Serial | | | | | | |Links | ======================================================================== |NNTP -- Network | Apr 90 | | | 977 |Network News | |News Transfer | | | | |Transfer Protocol | |Protocol | | | | | | ======================================================================== |SUPDUP -- | Jun 90 | | | 734 |SUPDUP Protocol | |Telnet option | | | | | | ======================================================================== |OSI IS-IS for IP| Sep 90 | | | 1195 |Use of OSI IS-IS | | | | | | |for Routing in | | | | | | |TCP/IP and Dual | | | | | | |Environments | ======================================================================== |Path MTU | Oct 90 | | | 1191 |Path MTU Discovery | |Discovery | | | | | | ======================================================================== |OIM-MIB-II | Jan 91 | | | 1214 |OSI Internet | | | | | | |Management: | | | | | | |Management | | | | | | |Information Base | ======================================================================== |IP over ARCNET | Feb 91 | | | 1201 |Transmitting IP | | | | | | |Traffic over ARCNET| | | | | | |Networks | ======================================================================== |802.4-MIB | Feb 91 | | | 1230 |IEEE 802.4 Token | | | | | | |Bus MIB | ======================================================================== |802.5-MIB | Feb 91 | | | 1231 |IEEE 802.5 Token | | | | | | |Ring MIB | ======================================================================== |DS1-MIB | Feb 91 | | | 1232 |Definitions of | | | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |the DS1 Interface | | | | | | |Type | ======================================================================== |DS3-MIB | Feb 91 | | | 1233 |Definitions of | | | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |the DS3 Interface | | | | | | |Type | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 7] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 |PPP Extensions | Apr 91 | | | 1220 |Point-to-Point | |for Bridging | | | | |Protocol Extensions| | | | | | |for Bridging | ======================================================================== |OSI-UDP -- | Apr 91 | | | 1240 |OSI Connectionless | |OSI CLTS over | | | | |Transport Services | |UDP | | | | |on top of UDP: | | | | | | |Version 1 | ======================================================================== |Generic | May 91 | | | 1229 |Extensions to the | |Interface MIB | | | | |Generic Interface | |Extensions | | | | |MIB | ======================================================================== |IPX over IP | May 91 | | | 1234 |Tunnelling IPX | | | | | | |Traffic through IP | | | | | | |Networks | ======================================================================== |AppleTalk MIB | May 91 | | | 1243 |AppleTalk | | | | | | |Management | | | | | | |Information Base | ======================================================================== |OSPF MIB | May 91 | | | 1253 |OSPF Version 2 | | | | | | |Management | | | | | | |Information Base | ======================================================================== |OSI NSAP | Jun 91 | | | 1237 |Guidelines for OSI | |Allocation | | | | |NSAP Allocation in | | | | | | |the Internet | ======================================================================== |ICMP Router | Sep 91 | | | 1256 |ICMP Router | |Discovery | | | | |Discovery Messages | | | | | | | | ======================================================================== |BGP MIB | Oct 91 | | | 1269 |Definitions of | | | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |the Border Gateway | | | | | | |Protocol (Vers. 3) | ======================================================================== |DoD IPSO -- US | Nov 91 | | | 1108 |US Department of | |Department of | | | | |Defense Security | |Defense IP | | | | |Options for the | |Security Option | | | | |Internet Protocol | ======================================================================== |Remote Monitor | Nov 91 | | | 1271 |Remote Network | |MIB | | | | |Monitoring Manage- | | | | | | |ment Information | | | | | | |Base | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 8] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== |X.500 Schema | Nov 91 | | | 1274 |The COSINE and | | | | | | |Internet X.500 | | | | | | |Schema | ======================================================================== |X.500 | Nov 91 | | | 1276 |Replication and | |Replication | | | | |Distributed Opera- | |and Distributed | | | | |tions Extensions | |Operations | | | | |to Provide an | |Extension | | | | |Internet Directory | | | | | | |Using X.500 | ======================================================================== |IP Addresses in | Nov 91 | | | 1277 |Encoding Network | |NSAP's | | | | |Addresses to | | | | | | |Support Operation | | | | | | |over non-OSI Layers| ======================================================================== |Bridge MIB | Dec 91 | | | 1286 |Definitions of | | | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |Bridges | ======================================================================== |DECNET Phase IV | Dec 91 | | | 1289 |DECnet Phase IV MIB| |MIB | | | | |Extensions | ======================================================================== |FDDI MIB | Jan 92 | | | 1285 |FDDI Management | | | | | | |Information Base | ======================================================================== |IARP -- Inverse | Jan 92 | | | 1293 |Inverse Address | |Address Resolu- | | | | |Resolution Protocol| |tion Protocol | | | | | | ======================================================================== |IP over Frame | Jan 92 | | | 1294 |Multiprotocol | |Relay | | | | |Interconect over | | | | | | |Frame Relay | ======================================================================== |NTP-3 -- | Mar 92 | | | 1305 |Network Time Proto-| |Network Time | | | | |col (Version 3) | |Protocol | | | | |Specification, | |Version 3 | | | | |Implementation, | | | | | | |and Analysis | ======================================================================== |NetFAX -- | Apr 92 | | | 1314 |A File Format for | |File Format for | | | | |the Exchange of | |the Exchange of | | | | |Images in the | |Images | | | | |Internet | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 9] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== |Frame Relay MIB | Apr 92 | | | 1315 |Management Informa-| | | | | | |tion Base for Frame| | | | | | |Relay DTEs | ======================================================================== |Character | Apr 92 | | | 1316 |Definitions of | |Stream Device | | | | |Managed Objects for| |MIB | | | | |Character Stream | | | | | | |Devices | ======================================================================== |RS-232 MIB | Apr 92 | | | 1317 |Definitions of | | | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |RS-232-like | | | | | | |Hardware Devices | ======================================================================== |Parallel | Apr 92 | | | 1318 |Definitions of | |Printer MIB | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |Parallel-Printer- | | | | | | |like Hardware | | | | | | |Devices | ======================================================================== |TCP Extensions | May 92 | | | 1323 |TCP Extensions for | |for High | | | | |High Performance | |Performance | | | | | | ======================================================================== |Mapping between | May 92 | | | 1327 |Mapping between | |X.400(1988)/ISO | | | | |X.400(1988)/ISO | |10021 and | | | | |10021 and RFC 922 | |RFC-822 | | | | | | ======================================================================== |Downgrading | May 92 | | | 1328 |X.400 1988 to 1984 | |X.400(1988) to | | | | |downgrading | |X.400(1984) | | | | | | ======================================================================== |PPP -- Point-to-| May 92 | | | 1331 |The Point-to-Point | |Point Protocol | | | | |Protocol (PPP) for | |(new version) | | | | |the Transmission of| | | | | | |Multi-protocol | | | | | | |Datagrams over | | | | | | |Point-to-Point | | | | | | |Links | ======================================================================== |IPCP -- PPP IP | May 92 | | | 1332 |The PPP Internet | |Control Protocol| | | | |Protocol Control | | | | | | |Protocol (IPCP) | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 10] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== |PPP Link Quality| May 92 | | | 1333 |PPP Link Quality | |Monitoring | | | | |Monitoring | ======================================================================== |MIME -- Multi- | Jun 92 | | | 1341 |MIME (Multipurpose | |purpose Mail | | | | |Internet Mail | |Extensions | | | | |Extensions): | | | | | | |Mechanisms for | | | | | | |Specifying and | | | | | | |Describing the | | | | | | |Format of Internet | | | | | | |Message Bodies | | | | | |==========================| | | | | | 1342 |Representation of | | | | | | |Non-ASCII Text in | | | | | | |Internet Message | | | | | | |Headers | ======================================================================== |TOS IP -- IP | Jul 92 | | | 1349 |Type of Service in | |Type of Service | | | | |the Internet Proto-| | | | | | |col Suite | ======================================================================== |SNMP Administra-| Jul 92 | | | 1351 |SNMP Administrative| |tive Model | | | | |Model | ======================================================================== |SNMP Security | Jul 92 | | | 1352 |SNMP Security | |Protocols | | | | |Protocols | ======================================================================== |SNMP Security | Jul 92 | | | 1353 |Definitions of | |MIB | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |Administration of | | | | | | |of SNMP Parties | ======================================================================== |IP Forwarding | Jul 92 | | | 1354 |IP Forwarding Table| |Table MIB | | | | |MIB | ======================================================================== |Multiprotocol | Jul 92 | | | 1356 |Multiprotocol | |Interconnect | | | | |Interconnect | |on X.25 and ISDN| | | | |on X.25 and ISDN | |in the Packet | | | | |in the Packet Mode | |Mode | | | | | | ======================================================================== |BGP OSPF | Aug 92 | | | 1364 |BGP OSPF | |Interaction | | | | |Interaction | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 11] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================= |Telnet Remote | Aug 92 | | | 1372 |Telnet Remote Flow | |Flow Control | | | | |Control Option | |Option | | | | | | ======================================================================= |IDPR -- | *Aug 92| | |in | | |InterDomain | | | | prep | | |Policy Routing | | | | | | ======================================================================= |PPP | Oct 92 | | | 1334 |PPP Authentication | |Authentication | | | | |Authentication | |Protocols | | | | | | ======================================================================= |802.3 Repeater | Oct 92 | | | 1368 |Definitions of | |MIB | | | | |Managed Objects for| | | | | | |IEEE 802.3 Repeater| | | | | | |Devices | ======================================================================= |OSPF | Oct 92 | | | 1370 |Applicability | |Applicability | | | | |Statement for OSPF | |Statement | | | | | | ======================================================================= |IP and ARP on | Oct 92 | | | 1374 |IP and ARP on HIPPI| |HIPPI | | | | | | ======================================================================= |DNCP -- PPP | Nov 92 | | | 1376 |The PPP DECnet | |DEC Phase IV | | | | |Phase IV Control | |Control Protocol| | | | |Protocol (DNCP) | ======================================================================= |OSINLCP -- PPP | Nov 92 | | | 1377 |The PPP OSI Network| |Network Layer | | | | |Layer Control | |Control Protocol| | | | |Protocol (OSINLCP) | ======================================================================= |ATCP -- PPP | Nov 92 | | | 1378 |The PPP Appletalk | |AppleTalk | | | | |Control Protocol | |Control Protocol| | | | |(ATCP) | ======================================================================= |MIB Extension | Nov 92 | | | 1381 |SNMP MIB Extension | |for LAPB | | | | |for X.25 LAPB | | | | | | | | ======================================================================= |MIB Extension | Nov 92 | | | 1382 |SNMP MIB Extension | |for X.25 Packet | | | | |for the X.25 | |Layer | | | | |Packet Layer | ======================================================================= |SNMP over | *Nov 92| | | in | | |OSI | | | | prep | | ======================================================================= Cooper [Page 12] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================= |SNMP over | *Nov 92| | | in | | |Appletalk | | | | prep | | ======================================================================= |SNMP over | *Nov 92| | | in | | |IPX | | | | prep | | ======================================================================= |BGP Default | *Nov 92| | | in | | |Route | | | | prep | | |Advertisement | | | | | | ======================================================================= |RIP Version 2 | *Dec 92| | | in | | | | | | | prep | | | | | | | | | ======================================================================= |MIB Extension | *Dec 92| | | in | | |for RIP Vers. 2 | | | | prep | | | | | | | | | ======================================================================= The following table summarizes all standards actions taken since September 1, 1991 that resulted in removing specifications from the standards track. These actions were recommended by the IESG and adopted by the IAB, in accordance with the procedures defined in RFC 1310. Some of these were obsoleted by later versions (as noted). The rest were the result of rationalizing the situation from before the institution of the formal procedures specified in RFC 1310. ======================================================================== | Description | Previous |Informational|Historic| RFC | RFC Title | | | Status | | | | | ======================================================================== |MIB-I -- | Internet | | Mar 92 | 1156 |Management | |Management | Standard | |Obs. by | |Information | |Information | Apr 90 | | STD 17,| |Base for | |Base | | |RFC 1213| |Network | | | | | | |Management of| | | | | | |TCP/IP-based | | | | | | |internets | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 13] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== |Mapping | Proposed | | May 92 | 987 |Mapping | |between X.400| Standard | |Obs. by | |between X.400| |and RFC-822 | Dec 88 | |RFC 1327| |and RFC-822 | | | | | |====================| | | | | | 1026 |Addendum to | | | | | | |RFC-987 | ======================================================================== |PEM -- | Draft | | May 92 | 1113 |Privacy | |Privacy- | Standard | | | |Enhancement | |Enhanced | Aug 89 | | | |for Internet | |Mail | | | | |Electronic | | | | | | |Mail: Part I-| | | | | | |- Message | | | | | | |Encipherment | | | | | | |and Authenti-| | | | | | |cation Pro- | | | | | | |cedures | | | | | |====================| | | | | | 1114 |Privacy | | | | | | |Enhancement | | | | | | |for Internet | | | | | | |Electronic | | | | | | |Mail: Part II| | | | | | |-- Certifi- | | | | | | |cate-Based | | | | | | |Key Manage- | | | | | | |ment | | | | | |====================| | | | | | 1115 |Privacy | | | | | | |Enhancement | | | | | | |for Internet | | | | | | |Electronic | | | | | | |Mail: Part | | | | | | |III -- | | | | | | |Algorithms, | | | | | | |Modes, and | | | | | | |Identifiers | ======================================================================== |PPP-INIT -- | Proposed | | May 92 | 1172 |The Point-to-| |PPP Initial | Standard | |Obs. by | |Point (PPP) | |Configuration| Jun 90 | |RFC 1331| |Initial | |Options | | | | |Configuration| | | | | | |Option | ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 14] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 ======================================================================== |SUPDUP | Proposed | | Jun 92 | 734 |SUPDUP | | | Standard | | | |Protocol | | | Dec 88 | | | | | ======================================================================== |SFTP -- | Proposed | | Jun 92 | 913 |Simple File | |Simple File | Standard | | | |Transfer | |Transfer | Dec 88 | | | |Protocol | |Protocol | | | | | | ======================================================================== |Hostname | Proposed | | Jun 92 | 953 |Hostname | |Server | Standard | | | |Server | | | Dec 88 | | | | | ======================================================================== |NFILE | Proposed | | Jun 92 | 1037 |NFILE - a | | | Standard | | | |File Access | | | Dec 88 | | | |Protocol | ======================================================================== |PCMAIL | Proposed | Jun 92 | | 1056 |PCMAIL - A | | | Standard | | | |Distributed | | | Dec 88 | | | |Mail System | | | | | | |for Personal | | | | | | |Computers | ======================================================================== Bob Braden (Braden@ISI.EDU) Cooper [Page 15] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 INTERNET ENGINEERING REPORTS ---------------------------- 1. The 25th meeting of the IETF, hosted by Sprint, was held in Washington DC from November 16-20. There were 690 registered attendees, a slight increase over the level achieved at the Boston IETF meeting held last July. We are currently entering attendee data and information from the Working Group rosters... and waiting for some to submit their minutes and reports for inclusion in the meeting proceedings. Following up on activities from the Cambridge IETF meeting last July, the 25th meeting opened with technical presentations on IPv7 candidates and proposals. Later in the week, a BOF was held to list and define criteria to be used for the evaluation of the various proposals. A presentation was made by the Poised working group on Tuesday and, following countless discussions and meetings, was the primary topic of discussion during the IESG Open Plenary where a concensus proposal was submitted to the IETF for disucsion. A follow up presentation will take place in December when the plan will be presented to the ISOC Board of Trustees. 2. I am pleased to announce that Stev Knowles has joined the IESG, and will serve with Phil Almquist as a Co-Area Director of the Internet Area. Stev is filling a slot left open when Noel Chiappa resigned. The Internet Area is an active one, and the addition of Stev will provide additional support to the area's activities. 3. The next IETF meeting is scheduled for Columbus, Ohio from March 29th through April 2, 1993 (yes, this does mean that the IESG Open Plenary will be held on April first). The meeting is being co-hosted by OARNet and The Ohio State University. There will be a registration reception on Sunday, March 28. Logistic and registration information will be forthcoming from the IETF Secretariat. The 27th meeting of the IETF, scheduled for July of 1993, will be held in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, and will be co-hosted by SURFnet and RARE. This will be the first time an IETF meeting has been held outside of North America. Negotiations are still in progress for the meeting facilities and catering arrangements, and there will be a higher fee for this meeting (estimated to be $200). More information will be provided as it becomes available. Cooper [Page 16] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 4. The IESG issued six Last Calls to the IETF during the month of November, 1992: a. Telnet Environment Option b. The Common Management Information Services and Protocols for the Internet c. Privacy Enhancement for Internet Electronic Mail: Part I: Message Encryption and Authentication Procedures d. Privacy Enhancement for Internet Electronic Mail: Part II: Certificate-Based Key Management e. Privacy Enhancement for Internet Electronic Mail: Part III: Algorithms, Modes, and Identifiers f. Privacy Enhancement for Internet Electronic Mail: Part IV: Key Certification and Related Services 5. The IESG made the following three recommendations to the IAB during the month of November, 1992: a. RIP Version 2 Carrying Additional Information be approved as a Proposed Standard. b. RIP Version 2 MIB Extension be approved as a Proposed Standard. c. RIP Version 2 Protocol Analysis be published as an Informational RFC. 6. Sixty-eight (68) Internet Draft actions were taken during the month of November, 1992: (Revised draft (o), New Draft (+) ) WG I-D Title -------- ---------------------------------------------------- (appleip) o A Method for the Transmission of Internet Packets Over AppleTalk Networks [MacIP] (dhc) o Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol (ospf) o OSPF Version 2 Traps (pem) o Privacy Enhancement for Internet Electronic Mail: Part III: Algorithms, Modes, and Identifiers (x400ops) o Routing coordination for X.400 MHS services within a multi protocol / multi network environment Cooper [Page 17] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 (dns) o DNS MIB Extensions (x400ops) o Operational Requirements for X.400 Management Domains in the GO-MHS Community (mhsds) o Representing Tables and Subtrees in the Directory (mhsds) o Use of the Directory to support mapping between X.400 and RFC 822 Addresses (mhsds) o MHS use of the Directory to support distribution lists (mhsds) o Representing the O/R Address hierarchy in the Directory Information Tree (mhsds) o Use of the Directory to support routing for RFC 822 and related protocols (mhsds) o A simple profile for MHS use of Directory (none) o Physical Link Security Type of Service (mhsds) o MHS use of Directory to support MHS Routing (ident) o Identification Server (atm) o Multiprotocol Interconnect over ATM Adaptation Layer 5 (x400ops) o X.400 use of extended character sets (none) o IP Address Encapsulation (IPAE): A Mechanism for Introducing a New IP (dhc) o DHCP Options and BOOTP Vendor Extensions (dhc) o Interoperation Between DHCP and BOOTP (mimemhs) o Equivalences between 1988 X.400 and RFC-822 Message Bodies (snmpv2) o Introduction to version 2 of the Internet Network ManagementFramework Cooper [Page 18] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 (snmpv2) o Protocol Operations for version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2) (snmpv2) o Coexistence between version 1 and version 2 of the Internet Network Management Framework (snmpv2) o Textual Conventions for for version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2) (snmpv2) o Transport Mappings for version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2) (snmpv2) o Structure of Management Information for version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2) (snmpv2) o Management Information Base for version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2) (snmpv2) o Manager to Manager Management Information Base (none) o Core Based Trees - Scalable Multicast Routing (smtpext) o SMTP Service Extensions (smtpext) o SMTP Service Extension for Message Size Declaration (none) o IP Version 7 Bibliography (pip) + The EIPIP Protocol: a Pip engine with an EIP shell (pip) + Transition to the Future Internet Protocol a comparison of three transition schemes (ospf) + OSPF Version 2 Management Information Base (pip) + Pip Identifiers (none) + Criteria for Choosing IP Version 7 (IPv7) (none) + TCP & UDP with Network-independent Endpoints (TUNE) (tuba) + Addressing and End Point Identification, For Use with TUBA (none) o IP Multicast over Token-Ring Local Area Networks (mhsds) + MHS use of Directory to support MHS Content Conversion Cooper [Page 19] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 (noop) + Tools RFC (noop) + An Echo Function for ISO 8473 (none) + Simple Internet Protocol (SIP) Specification (ospf) + OSPF Version 2 (noctool2) + FYI on a Network Management Tool Catalog: Tools for Monitoring and Debugging TCP/IP Internets and Interconnected Devices (ipae) + IPv7 Criteria Analysis for IP Address Encapsulation (IPAE) and the Simple Internet Protocol (SIP) (ipae) + IP Address Encapsulation (IPAE): A Mechanism for Introducing a New IP (iab) + Draft revision to RFC-1310--The Internet Standards Process (pip) + IPv7 Criteria Analysis for EIPIP (wnils) + Architecture of the Whois++ Index Service (x400ops) + Postmaster Convention for X.400 Operations (none) + ISO/CCITT and Internet Management Coexistence (IIMC): Translation of Internet MIB-II (RFC1213) to ISO/CCITT GDMO MIB (IIMCMIB-II) (none) + Routing over Demand Circuits on Wide Area Networks-RIP (none) + ISO/CCITT and Internet Management Coexistence (IIMC): Translation of ISO/CCITT GDMO MIBs to Internet MIBs (IIMCOMIBTRANS) (none) + ISO/CCITT and Internet Management Coexistence (IIMC): Translation of Internet Party MIB (RFC1353) to ISO/CCITT GDMO MIB (IIMCPARTY) (none) + ISO/CCITT and Internet Management Coexistence (IIMC): Translation of Internet MIBs to ISO/CCITT GDMO MIBs (IIMCIMIBTRANS) (none) + ISO/CCITT and Internet Management Coexistence (IIMC): ISO/CCITT to Internet Management Proxy (IIMCPROXY) Cooper [Page 20] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 (pem) + MIME-PEM Interaction (trunkmib) + Definitions of Managed Objects for the DS1 and E1 Interface Types (trunkmib) o Definitions of Managed Objects for the DS3/E3 Interface Type (none) + RFC 1327 tutorial (snmpv2) + Conformance Statements for version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2) (smtpext) + SMTP Service Extension for 8bit-MIMEtransport (smtpext) + Transition of Internet Mail from Just-Send-8 to 8Bit-SMTP/MIME (none) + DNS NSAP RRs 7. Ten (10) RFC's were published during the month of November, 1992. RFC St WG Title ------- -- ------- ------------------------------------------ RFC1374 PS (none) IP and ARP on HIPPI RFC1375 I (none) Suggestion for New Classes of IP Addresses RFC1376 PS (pppext) The PPP DECnet Phase IV Control Protocol (DNCP) RFC1377 PS (pppext) The PPP OSI Network Layer Control Protocol (OSINLCP) RFC1378 PS (pppext) The PPP AppleTalk Control Protocol (ATCP) RFC1379 I (none) Extending TCP for Transactions -- Concepts RFC1380 I (iesg) IESG Deliberations on Routing and Addressing RFC1381 PS (x25mib) SNMP MIB Extension for X.25 LAPB RFC1382 PS (x25mib) SNMP MIB Extension for the X.25 Packet Layer RFC1385 I (none) EIP: The Extended Internet Protocol A Framework for Maintaining Backward Compatibility Cooper [Page 21] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 St(atus): ( S) Internet Standard (PS) Proposed Standard (DS) Draft Standard ( E) Experimental ( I) Informational Steve Coya (scoya@nri.reston.va.us) Phill Gross (pgross@nis.ans.net) Cooper [Page 22] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 INTERNET PROJECTS ----------------- CIX (COMMERCIAL INTERNET EXCHANGE) ---------------------------------- The following report outlines CIX-WEST usage for the month of November, 1992. CIX In Out Member Octets Packets Errors Octets Packets Errors --------- ---------------------------- -------------------------- AlterNet 39779819715 172211253 2527 26696994890 188374428 0 CERFnet 30048543654 169759904 1319 26830057357 133294341 0 PSINet 25075976737 171562537 37 43662455689 195964631 0 SprintNet 2910054044 10447052 1848 811765813 7081335 0 Starting: Nov 5 1992 at 09:19 Ending: Dec 1 1992 at 00:08 SNMP Polling Intervals: 3659 SNMP Polling Frequency: 15 minutes In - traffic entering the CIX from the CIX member network Out - traffic exiting the CIX into the CIX member network ----- At the present time, approximately 1250 networks within the CIX membership are using the CIX-WEST. The CIX membership currently routing through CIX-WEST consists of: AlterNet CERFnet PSINet SprintLink The Nordic Carriers (via AlterNet) EUNET (via AlterNet) PIPEX (via AlterNet) Send mail to info@cix.org for information regarding the CIX. Mark Fedor (fedor@uu.psi.com) Cooper [Page 23] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 CONCERT ------- CONCERT Report for October / November ------------------------------------- The MCNC Center for Communications received a three year grant from the NSF to support its Clearinghouse for Networked Information Discovery and Retrieval (CNIDR). CNIDR is working closely with the IETF working groups and other international associations to further the development and appropriate uses of networked information. As one its its first focal points, the CNIDR will work with developers of WAIS tools toward providing compatibility and consistency, and, to the extent possible, convergence of the tools. The HILDA HiPPI network analysis system has been used extensively to debug and test the VISTAnet Gigabit network testbed. We have measured the network usage and performance characteristics of the VISTAnet medical application. Initial traffic analysis indicates: a) Very bursty interpacket arrival times. b) Very high correlation coefficients. c) Fixed size packets. Packets are either very short or very long. d) Average data rate of 153Mbps during the bursty traffic times. The HILDA HiPPI network analysis system was demonstrated and used at the Supercomputing 92 conference. Both Input/Output Systems Corporation and Los Alamos National Labs brought a HILDA system. Measurements were made on the performance and characteristics of network traffic between the show floor (at the Minneapolis Convention center) and the Cray Research facility at Eagan MN. These sites were separated by 40km. These measurements represent the first High Speed Network measurements for a long distance HiPPI network of general purpose network traffic. XTP (Xpress Transfer Protocol) is now operational on our CRAY Y-MP under UNICOS 6.16. Version 3.5 of XTP from Protocol Engines was ported to the CRAY and tested over the high speed HiPPI network interface. No performance figures are available yet. This is the first use of alternate transport and network protocols over the high speed HiPPI network from a CRAY Y-MP. Representatives from several small North Carolina Colleges attended a meeting held at CONCERT in order to help them evaluate potential Internet connections. Cooper [Page 24] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 CONCERT staff assisted with debugging and testing the INRIA Videoconferencing System (IVS) which was used to broadcast part of the Washington DC IETF meeting. A version of IVS using the Tk toolkit, instead of the original MOTIF toolkit, was developed and made available via anonymous FTP from ftp.concert.net. Several CONCERT staff members attended the 25th IETF meeting held in Washington DC. by Tom Sandoski ISI --- GIGABIT NETWORKING Infrastructure Bob Braden, Steve Casner, Eve Schooler, Jon Postel, and Joyce Reynolds, attended IETF and IAB meetings November 17-22, 1992 in Washington D.C. Joyce Reynolds attended meetings in Brisbane Australia for Networkshop '92, and Toyko, Japan, for meetings with the NIC committee. Joe Touch installed ACT equipment at DARPA and gave a presentation in Philadelphia November 10-11, 1992. Greg Finn attended meetings at Digital Equip Corp, Palo Alto, November 12, 1992. Eight RFCs were published this month. RFC 1376: Senum, S., "The PPP DECnet Phase IV Control Protocol (DNCP)", Network Systems Corporation, November 1992. RFC 1377: Katz, D., "The PPP OSI Network Layer Control Protocol (OSINLCP)", Cisco, November 1992. RFC 1378: Parker, B., "The PPP AppleTalk Control Protocol (ATCP)", Cayman Systems, November 1992. RFC 1379: Braden, B., "Extending TCP for Transactions -- Concepts", USC/ISI, November 1992. RFC 1380: Gross, P., IESG Chair, P. Almquist, IESG Internet AD, "IESG Deliberations on Routing and Addressing", November 1992. RFC 1381: Throop, D. (Data General Corporation), F. Baker (Advanced Computer Communicatioms), "SNMP MIB Extension for X.25 LAPB", November 1992. Cooper [Page 25] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 RFC 1382: Throop, D., Editor (Data General Corporation), "SNMP MIB Extension for the X.25 Packet Layer", November 1992. RFC 1385: Wang, Z., "EIP: The Extended Internet Protocol A Framework for Maintaining Backward Compatibility", University College London, November 1992. Ann Westine Cooper (Cooper@ISI.EDU) MULTIMEDIA CONFERENCING At the November IETF meeting, there were several advances on the teleconferencing front. This was the third meeting to be "audiocast" and the second to include video, this time over the MBONE (virtual multicast backbone) built up in a more coordinated manner from the ad-hoc collection of multicast tunnels used in July. In the Audio/Video Transport WG chaired by Steve Casner, a draft specification for the Realtime Transport Protocol, based on previous WG discussion, was presented by Henning Schulzrinne. We reached consensus on most of the open issues. A collection of Internet-Drafts will be released very soon. In the third session, we heard presentations on the software video compression algorithms being used in various programs and discussed how we might achieve interoperation among them. Eve Schooler led two impromptu BOF sessions on Conference Control (sometimes referred to as connection or configuration management). The aim of these discussions was to understand how such a group might contribute to the remote conferencing architecture effort. It was agreed that there is a need for a session layer control protocol to perform higher layer functions than the protocol proposed in the AVT WG. The beginnings of design criteria for this protocol were identified. See the minutes in the IETF proceedings for further details. Eve Schooler and Steve Casner attended the 3rd International Workshop on Network and Operating System Support for Digital Audio and Video and presented a paper "The Impact of Scaling on a Multimedia Connection Architecture". Eve Schooler (schooler@isi.edu) Cooper [Page 26] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 JVNCNET ------- JvNCnet-Global Enterprise Services, Inc. JvNCnet-Global Enterprise Services, Inc. B6 von Neumann Hall, Princeton, NJ 08544 1-800-35-TIGER New Information A. New on-line members (fully operational November 1992) CFD Research Corporation, Bloomfield, NJ DataPro, Mt. Laurel, NJ Expert Economics, Haverford, PA Foster Wheeler USA, Corp., Clinton, NJ Justlaws, Inc., New York, NY Micra, Inc., Plainfield, NJ Mystic Seaport Museum, Mystic, CT Okidata, Mt. Laurel, NJ SAI Systems Laboratories, Inc., Shelton, CT Sharp Electronics, Mahwah, NJ Thinking Machines, Cambridge, MA B. JvNCnet Members Meeting February 5, 1993 - Princeton Marriott Forrestal, Forrestal Village, College Road, Plainsboro, NJ C. JvNCnet Symposium Title: Internet Resources and Applications Date: Friday, February 19, 1993 Location: Princeton Marriott Forrestal, Forrestal Village, College Road, Plainsboro, NJ (5 min. north of Princeton) Focus: What is Internet. Functions of Internet, e.g., ftp, telnet, email How to bring both information and communications to the desktop. Description of several useful and interesting applications and resources. Cooper [Page 27] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Audience: New and intermediate Internet users Anyone who wants to learn about the numerous advantages of using the Internet to realize effective and productive work. Speakers: A group of invited experts will describe the value of Internetworking, how to 'navigate' Internet, how to use popular network tools such as WAIS, to assist one's navigation, and several other resources at parallel sessions. Additional information (agenda, directions, cost) about this symposium and others will be announced. Rochelle Hammer (hammer@jvnc.net) LOS NETTOS ---------- A M-Bone router was added to Los Nettos to accept multicast data from the Internet and forward it to member sites. This was used during the IETF multicast successfully. The network remains stable. No line outages or equipment failures have occured for some time. Walt Prue (Prue@ISI.EDU) NEARNET (NEW ENGLAND ACADEMIC AND RESEARCH NETWORK) --------------------------------------------------- Commercial Routing Option Announcement ====================================== NEARnet announced its commercial routing option this month. This option gives NEARnet members commercial access to all CIX and ANS CO+RE networks. For more information, send a message to: nearnet- join@nic.near.net or call (617) 873-8730. NEARnet Membership ================== As of November 23, 1992, NEARnet has grown to a total of 176 member organizations. Cooper [Page 28] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 EFF and IETF Conference Participation ===================================== John Rugo attended the K-12 Internet Access Roundtable meeting on Hosted by Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) in Washington, DC on Friday, November 13. Dan Long and John Curran participated in several working group sessions at the IETF in Washington, DC during the week of November 16. NEARnet Mini-Seminar Series Update ================================== The sixth seminar of the NEARnet Mini-Seminar Series for 1992 was held on November 6, from 1:00 p.m. to 4:30 p.m. at BBN's Newman Auditorium. Close to 80 participants attended the seminar which focused on upcoming protocols and applications in the Internet, such as: OSI, ISODE, X.500, IP Multicasting, Privacy Enhanced Mail (PEM), and WAIS (the Wide Area Information Server). The seminar began with an introduction of OSI, ISODE, X.500, and IP Multicasting by John Curran of the NEARnet Staff. John then began a live desktop video conference with Carl Howe of the BBN multimedia communications group. Following the video conference, Mark Feldman of Trusted Information Systems gave a presentation on Internet Privacy-Enhanced Mail (PEM). The seminar concluded with a discussion of the Wide Area Information Server (WAIS). Annual NEARnet Seminar Announcement =================================== The Annual NEARnet Seminar for 1992 is scheduled for Wednesday, December 16, from 9:00-4:00 at the Brandeis University Events Center in Waltham, Massachusetts. The keynote speaker will be Henry H. Perritt, Jr., professor of law at Villanova University School of Law, and author of several publications in the area of commercialization and legal issues related to electronic networks. Dr. Perritt's presentation will include legal issues dealing with first ammendment rights, rights of access, and tort and criminal liability of network intermediaries. Guest speakers will include: Peter Deutch, President of Bunyip Information Systems Inc., and co-architect of the Internet information indexing service, Archie; Mohamed Ellozy of the Dana Farber Cancer Institute and member of the Longwood Medical Area's Fiber Optic Network (LMAnet); and Tracy LaQuey Parker, a Network Information Specialist at the University of Texas System, Office of Cooper [Page 29] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Telecommunication Services and author of "The Internet Companion: A Beginner's Guide to Global Networking". In addition to the keynote address, topics covered at the seminar will include an overview of NEARnet and discussion of NEARnet's Commercial Routing Service, integrating heterogeneous mail systems, Multimedia Electronic Mail (MIME), and an overview of the future of internet tools, services and information. A copy of the seminar announcement, directions and registration form are available via anonymous FTP at nic.near.net in the pathname: seminars/annual-seminar-announcement. For more information on the annual seminar, please send mail to the NEARnet User Services Staff at nearnet-us@nic.near.net, or call 617-873- 8730, press option 0 or 6. NEARnet Seminar Videotape Collection ==================================== NEARnet members may borrow videotapes of several NEARnet Technical and User Seminars. A list of NEARnet's videotape collection is available via anonymous FTP from nic.near.net in the file: seminars/nearnet-video-tapes. "NEARnet This Month" Bulletin ============================= The October and November issues of the "NEARnet This Month" bulletin have been distributed. Past issues are available via anonymous FTP at nic.near.net, in the directory newsletters/nearnet-this-month. by Corinne Carroll NNSC, UCAR/BOLT BERANEK and NEWMAN, INC. ---------------------------------------- Policies and Procedures Project =============================== The first results of the NNSC policies and procedures project are now available via anonymous FTP at nnsc.nsf.net in the policies- procedures directory. This project is being done as an effort to learn how administrators at colleges, universities, K-12 schools, libraries, and museums can guide their users to make the best use of the Internet while at the same time avoid common difficulites. Cooper [Page 30] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 To submit documents for this directory, send mail to: pol-proc-doc@nnsc.nsf.net. To participate in the new policies and procedures mailing list, send mail to: pol-proc@nnsc.nsf.net. To join this mailing list, send mail to: pol-proc-request@nnsc.nsf.net. IETF Participation ================== Craig Partridge, Charlotte Mooers, and Cyndi Mills participated in various working group sessions on IP addressing, user services, and Internet accounting issues at the IETF in Washington, DC during the week of November 16. Internet Resource Guide Update ============================== The NNSC has completed an up-to-date November 1992 version of the Internet Resource Guide. The revised guide has a total of 150 sections, separated into seven individual chapters. Seventy entries were updated in 1992 and 14 are new since November 1991; the remaining 66, which date from before November 1991, are "old". We expect to get them updated soon. We also hope to get many new entries in the near future. If you know of a resource that we should list, please send an e-mail message to "resource-guide@nnsc.nsf.net", and we will send a template and instructions for preparing the entry. Corinne Carroll NORTHWESTNET ------------ A recently awarded NSF grant has paved the way for a collaborative effort between NorthWestNet, the University of Washington College of Engineering, and the University of Washington Computing & Communications to recruit and retain students with disabilities into the sciences and engineering. The grant's Steering Committee is now laying the foundation for implementation of this three-year program. Participating high school sophomores and juniors with disabilities will be paired with a mentor group of scientists and engineers, most of whom are themselves disabled. Participants will be provided with access to electronic mail and Internet resources and trained to use these tools. This common forum will allow students and mentors to discuss science and issues concerning disabilities throughout the year. Cooper [Page 31] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Each summer the students will participate in a two-week long, live-in program at the University. During this time they will study science and engineering using computer applications, educational software, electronic mail, and Internet resources. In addition, quarterly workshops will be held to educate faculty, staff, and students about the barriers faced by students with disabilities and offer practical approaches for removing those barriers. NorthWestNet's role in this grant will focus on providing Internet access to the participants: training them to use e-mail, FTP, and Telnet so that they can fully utilize the Internet's resources and providing on-going support for use of these resources. NorthWestNet 15400 SE 30th Place, Suite 202 Phone: (206) 562-3000 Bellevue, WA 98007 Fax: (206) 562-4822 Dr. Eric S. Hood, Executive Director Jan Eveleth, Director of User Services Dan L. Jordt, Director of Technical Services Anthony Naughtin, Manager of Member Relations NorthWestNet serves the six state region of Alaska, Idaho, Montana, North Dakota, Oregon, and Washington. Jan Eveleth NSFNET/ANSNET BACKBONE ENGINEERING ---------------------------------- There are two reports for ANSNET/NSFNET this month, October and November. OCTOBER 1992 T3 Backbone Status ================== During October, the T3 network router software was upgraded to support 10,000 destination networks with up to four routes per destination. Development work in support of migration to GATED routing software continues on schedule. Problems that were addressed in October included a major routing software bug that resulted in 3 separate routing instability events, an RS960 memory parity problem, and an AIX TCP software Cooper [Page 32] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 bug. The phase-4 backbone upgrade activities were completed in October. Significant positive experience was gained with the RS960 FDDI interface in October that will lead to additional FDDI deployments on T3 ENSS nodes. The preparations continued for dismantling of the T1 backbone which is scheduled for November. Activities included testing of OSI CLNP encapsulation over the T1 backbone, deployment of the redundant backup circuits for the T3 ENSS gateways at each regional network, collection of network source/destination traffic statistics on the T3 backbone, and cutover of the ESnet networks to the T3 backbone. The EASInet and CA*Net systems are not yet using the T3 backbone, and will be cutover in November. Backbone Traffic and Routing Statistics ======================================= The total inbound packet count for the T1 network was 4,213,308,629, up 20.0% from September. 469,891,322 of these packets entered from the T3 network. The total inbound packet count for the T3 network was 18,940,301,000 up 20.8% from September. 185,369,688 of these packets entered from the T1 network. The combined total inbound packet count for the T1 and T3 networks (less cross network traffic) was 22,498,348,619 up 20.1% from September. As of October 31, the number of networks configured in the NSFNET Policy Routing Database was 7354 for the T1 backbone, and 7046 for the T3 backbone. Of these, 1343 networks were never announced to the T1 backbone and 1244 were never announced to the T3 backbone. For the T1, the maximum number of networks announced to the backbone during the month (from samples collected every 15 minutes) was 5378; on the T3 the maximum number of announced networks was 5124. Average announced networks on 10/31 were 5335 to T1, and 5085 to T3. Routing Software on the T3 Network ================================== During October, the T3 network routing and system software was upgraded to support an increased on-card routing table size on the RS960 interfaces (T3/FDDI) and T960 interface (T1/ethernet) to 10,000 destination networks with up to 4 alternate routes per Cooper [Page 33] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 destination network. The previous limit was 6000 destinations networks with up to 4 alternate routes per destination. A serious routing bug was exposed that caused instabilities across the entire T3 system during three different events, the first on 10/19, and the 2nd & 3rd on 10/23. We successfully installed a new version of rcp_routed software on all T3 backbone nodes to fix the problem. This bug involved the interface between the routing daemon, and the SNMP subagent. With the addition of the 86th AS peer on the T3 backbone, the buffer between the routing daemon and the SNMP subagent would get corrupted and induce a failure of the routing software. With the increased number of routes in the on-card routing tables, we have begun to observe problems with the performance for route installs/deletes between the on-card forwarding tables, and the AIX kernel. During transient routing conditions we may experience high card/system traffic due to route downloads which can cause transient instabilities. We plan to deploy new software that will improve the efficiency for route installs/deletes between the on- card forwarding tables, and the AIX kernel in November. Also during November, we plan to install new routing software that will support static routes. This can be used for situations where there is no peer router available to announce the shared interface and any networks behind it. This version of the routing software will also selectively filter routes out of the local routing tables on a network and/or AS basis. The software will also increase the limit to 16 peer AS numbers per ENSS, and improve the checks for the size of BGP updates and attributes. The development of GATED software to replace the rcp_routed software base is proceeding on schedule. During October, the BGP4 protocol was developed and unit tested in GATED along with the interim link state IGP that will be used to interoperate with internal nodes running rcp_routed. We expect to deploy GATED software on the T3 network in early 1993 following the upgrade to the AIX 3.2 operating system. RS960 Memory Parity Problem =========================== During October, we continued to experience some problems on CNSS nodes due to the failure of parity checking logic within the on- card memory on selected RS960 T3 adapters. These problems have largely been isolated to a few specific nodes including CNSS97 (Denver), CNSS32 (New York), and CNSS40 (Cleveland). These outages do not generally result in ENSS isolation from the network since Cooper [Page 34] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 only a single interface will be affected, and redundant connectivity is employed on other CNSS interfaces. The problem can be cleared by a software reset of the interface. Some of these problems have been alleviated with hardware replacement (e.g. CNSS97 in Denver). AIX TCP Software Problem ======================== During October we experienced a problem involving TCP session deadlock involving I-BGP sessions between particular ENSS routers. A bug was found in the TCP implementation of the AIX 3.1 operating system (same bug in BSD) where an established TCP session between two ENSS routers (e.g. for I-BGP information transfer) would hang and induce a high traffic condition between an RS960 T3 interface and the RS/6000 system processor. This would cause one of the ENSS routers on either end of the TCP session to suffer from performance problems, until the problem was cleared with a reboot. This problem occurred on several ENSS nodes in October including ENSS134 (Boston), ENSS144 (Ames), ENSS131 (Ann Arbor), and ENSS129 (Champaign). A fix to this problem was identified, and successfully tested in October. This will be released as part of a new system software build for the RS/6000 router in November. Phase-4 Deployment Complete =========================== The phase-4 network upgrade was completed in October '92. The final steps in the upgrade involved the installation of CNSS36 in the New York POP, and the completion of T3 DSU PROM upgrades. The DSU firmware upgrade supports new c-bit parity monitoring features, and incorporates several bug fixes. RS960 FDDI Deployment Status ============================ Since the installation of the new RS960 FDDI adapters for the RS/6000 router on ENSS128 (Palo Alto), ENSS135 (San Diego), ENSS129 (Champaign), and ENSS132 (Pittsburgh), there have been only two operational problems. One involved an instance of backlevel microcode following a software update, and the other involved a failure of the original hardware installed. The experience with RS960 FDDI has been extremely positive so far. There are performance tests under way involving Pittsburgh Supercomputer Center, San Diego Supercomputer Center, and National Cooper [Page 35] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Center for Supercomputer Applications that are designed to exploit the FDDI high bandwidth capability. Following the completion of these tests, additional RS960 FDDI adapters will be deployed. All production network interfaces are still configured for a 1500 byte Maximum Transmission Unit (MTU). We will soon reconfigure the MTU on most network interfaces to maximize performance for applications designed to exploit T3/FDDI bandwidth, while maintaining satisfactory performance for sites that interconnect to the T3 routers via an ethernet- only interface. The new configuration will be: o Any ENSS with an RS960 FDDI interface will have a 4000 byte MTU except for the ethernet interfaces which will remain at 1500 bytes. The FDDI interface MTU will be set to 4352 bytes following the deployment of AIX 3.2. o All other ENSS ethernet interfaces will have a 1500 byte MTU o All T3 CNSS interfaces will have a 4000 byte MTU except T3 interfaces connecting to an ENSS with ethernet only, and interfaces connecting to a T1 CNSS. o All T1 CNSS interfaces and T1 ENSS interfaces will have a 1500 byte MTU. Dismantling the T1 Backbone =========================== Plans to dismantle the T1 backbone have proceeded on schedule. We will begin dismantling the T1 backbone in November '92. This will occur as soon as (1) the remaining networks using the T1 backbone are cut over to the T3 backbone (EASInet and CA*net); (2) the OSI CLNP encapsulation support for the T3 backbone is deployed; (3) the T3 ENSS nodes are backed up by additional T1 circuits terminating at alternate backbone POPs. These activities are described below. T1 Routing Announcement Change ------------------------------ In early November a change will be made to eliminate the redundant announcements of networks from the T3 to the T1 backbone via the interconnect, for those networks which are announced to both backbones. This has the effect of eliminating the use of the T1/T3 interconnect gateway for CA*Net and EASInet in the case of isolation of a multi-homed regional from the T1 backbone. This change is necessary for the interim to allow these duplicate routes to be removed from the overloaded routing tables on the T1 RCP Cooper [Page 36] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 nodes, and to allow the T1 backbone to be used for a few more weeks. Remaining Network Cutovers to T3 -------------------------------- A new T1 ENSS will be installed in CERN, Switzerland to provide connectivity to the T3 backbone for EASInet. Cutover of EASInet traffic will occur when this installation is complete. The Seattle RT E-PSP for CA*net is being converted to run the CA*net software and operate as part of CA*net's domain. It will run GATED and speak BGP with the T3 ENSS. Once this has been debugged and tested the Princeton and Ithaca connections will similarly be upgraded. OSI Support Plan ---------------- We have successfully tested the RT/PC OSI encapsulator software (EON) that was described in the August '92 engineering report. Because the encapsulator software uses IP to route encapsulated OSI traffic, this can be tested over the production T1 network. Encapsulation is enabled in one way mode from NSS17 in Ann Arbor to selected NSAP prefixes (i.e. encapsulation outgoing, native CLNP incoming). The half duplex capability is important for testing and deployment. When any of the T1 NSFNET EPSP nodes receive an encapsulated OSI packet, it decodes it and proceeds to switch it via native CLNP. The OSI encapsulator EPSP is configured on a per prefix basis (e.g. any prefix configured to use EON at a given NSS will have its outgoing packets encapsulated). This flexibility in configuration will allow us to switch two regional networks over to OSI encapsulation during the 2nd week of November, with full conversion to OSI encapsulation during the 3rd week of November. Native CLNP switching services will be available in an upcoming release of the RS/6000 AIX 3.2 system software which is scheduled for deployment on the T3 network in early 1993. Cooper [Page 37] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 T3 ENSS Backup Plan ------------------- The plan to provide backup connectivity to T3 ENSS nodes proceeded on schedule in October. We have begun to install dedicated T1 leased line circuits between all T3 ENSS nodes, and a CNSS T1 router in a secondary POP. These T1 circuits are replacing T1 router ports that were formerly used by T1 safetynet circuits on the T1 CNSS routers. This work is expected to be complete by the end of November. The planned topology for T3 ENSS backup is illustrated in a postscript map that is available via anonymous FTP on ftp.ans.net in the file . Once the backup infrastructure is in place, we will begin to work on subsequent optimizations to further improve backup connectivity. We have already begun discussions with several regional networks on this. Several regionals have indicated that they will stop peering with the T1 backbone when their T1 ENSS backup circuit is in place. The final phaseout of the T1 backbone will occur after OSI encapsulation, final traffic cutovers, and these backup circuits are installed. Network Source/Destination Statistics Collection ================================================ During October we tested and deployed software on the T3 backbone to collect network source/destination traffic statistics. This is a feature that has been supported on the T1 backbone in the past, and was supported for a brief period on the T3 backbone prior to the migration to RS960 switching technology. For each ENSS local area network interface, we will collect the following information for each source/destination network pair: packets (in and out), bytes (in and out), packets distributed by port#, packets distributed by protocol type (UDP, TCP). Packets are sampled on the card (1 in 50 packets sampled) and forwarded to the system processor for reduction and storage. We expect to have collected a full month of network source/destination statistics by the end of November. Notable Outages in October ========================== MCI Fiber Outage - 10/17 ------------------------ At 12:33EST on 10/17 we experienced a major MCI fiber outage on the Cooper [Page 38] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 east coast. A truck accident damaged a fiber-line between Trenton and New Brunswick (New Jersey). This caused an extended loss of connectivity for several T3 and T1 circuits that transited the MCI junction in West Orange New Jersey. All circuits affected by the fiber cut were back on their original path as of 10/17/92 22:00 EDT. During the outage, several circuits were moved to backup restoration facilities and were moved back during the early morning of 10/18. There were some periods of routing instability with circuits going down and coming back up that caused temporary loss of connectivity for other network sites as well. Routing Software Instabilities - 10/19, 10/23 --------------------------------------------- During the week of October 19th, the T3 network experienced 3 unscheduled outages (roughly 1 hour each in duration). We successfully installed a new version of rcp_routed software on all T3 backbone nodes that fixed the problem on 10/25. This bug involved the interface between the routing daemon, and the SNMP subagent. With the addition of the 86th AS peer on the T3 backbone, the buffer between the routing daemon and the SNMP subagent would get corrupted and induce a crash of the routing software. This problem occurred first during the cutover of the ESnet peers at FIX-E, and FIX-W on 10/19. Following the resolution of this problem, the ESnet peers were successfully cutover to use the T3 backbone. Jordan Becker (becker@ans.net) Mark Knopper (mak@merit.edu) +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ NOVEMBER 1992 Network Status Summary ====================== All remaining T1 backbone traffic was cutover to the T3 backbone and the T1 backbone network was turned off on December 2nd. There were network stability problems observed at several sites prior to, and during the IETF MBONE video/audio multicast event in November. The problems were mostly due to increased traffic, and the inefficient processing of source route packets that caused routing instabilities. Cooper [Page 39] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Software changes have been deployed on the T3 backbone to reduce the routing instability problems due the MBONE, and to improve the efficiency for downloading large routing updates to the packet forwarding interfaces on the T3 routers. New RS960 FDDI interfaces are being scheduled for deployment to selected T3 ENSS nodes in December. Performance measurements over the T3 network are proceeding at sites that already have FDDI interfaces installed. Backbone Traffic and Routing Statistics ======================================= The total inbound packet count for the T1 network was 3,589,916,970, down 14.8% from October. 598,015,432 of these packets entered from the T3 network. The total inbound packet count for the T3 network was 20,968,465,293, up 10.7% from October. 134,269,388 of these packets entered from the T1 network. The combined total inbound packet count for the T1 and T3 networks (less cross network traffic) was 23,826,097,443 up 5.9% from October. As of November 30, the number of networks configured in the NSFNET Policy Routing Database was 7833 for the T1 backbone, and 7581 for the T3 backbone. Of these, 1642 networks were never announced to the T1 backbone and 1602 were never announced to the T3 backbone. For the T1, the maximum number of networks announced to the backbone during the month (from samples collected every 15 minutes) was 5772; on the T3 the maximum number of announced networks was 5548. Average announced networks on 11/30 were 5707 to T1, and 5495 to T3. T1 NSFNET Backbone Turned Off ============================= The activities required to turn off the T1 backbone were completed during November and the network was officially turned off by disabling routing on the NSS nodes starting at 00:01 EST on 12/2. Several actions were taken in advance of the routing shutdown including installation of the T1 ENSS206 at CERN in Switzerland, reconfiguration of the T1 NSS routers to gateway traffic between CA*net and NSFNET, the deployment of the EON software for OSI encapsulation over IP, and the final installation of T1 backup circuit infrastructure connecting T3 ENSS nodes to secondary CNSS nodes. Cooper [Page 40] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Remaining Network Cutovers to T3 -------------------------------- AS 68, Los Alamos National Laboratory networks and AS22, operated by MilNet at the San Diego Supercomputer Center were cutover to use the T3 backbone in November. A new T1 ENSS (ENSS206) was installed in CERN, Switzerland to provide connectivity to the T3 backbone for EASInet. ENSS206 is interconnected via a T1 circuit with CNSS35 in New York City. The ENSS was initially configured with less than the recommended memory, and had to be upgraded to overcome some performance problems. Other than that, the installation went smoothly, and EASInet traffic was cutover to the T3 backbone on 12/1. The NSS nodes in Seattle, Ithaca and Princeton were converted for use by CA*net to allow CA*net to peer with the T3 network until the longer term GATED hardware peer configurations are available. The E-PSP nodes for CA*net will be converted to run the CA*net software and operate as part of CA*net's domain. These nodes will run GATED and exchange routes via BGP with the T3 ENSS. OSI Support on T3 Backbone -------------------------- OSI CLNP forwarding over the T3 backbone was configured via encapsulation of CLNP over IP packets using the EON method (RFC1070) until native CLNP switching services are available on the T3 routers. RT PSP routers were configured as EON encapsulators at most regional and peer networks. CLNP traffic on the regional is first routed to the EON machine. The EON machine encapsulates the CLNP packet in an IP packet. The EON machine will send the IP packet to the remote EON machine that is associated with the destination NSAP address prefix in the CLNP packet. The IP packet generated by EON will contain the source address of the EON machine, and the destination address of the EON machine. The following static mapping tables will exist in the EON machines: NSAP Prefix -> remote IP address of EON machine to decapsulate the IP packet into a CLNP packet. For local NETs of Router: NSAP Prefix -> local NET of router on the ethernet to route the traffic off the NSFNET service Changes or requests to be added to these tables should be sent to nsfnet-admin@merit.edu. Cooper [Page 41] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 The support for CLNP native switching services on the T3 backbone proceeded to be tested in November. The AIX 3.2 system software that supports CLNP switching is in system test and is expected to be available on the T3 backbone in February '93. T3 ENSS Backup Plan ------------------- The installation and testing of dedicated T1 leased line circuits between all T3 ENSS nodes, and a CNSS T1 router in a secondary POP was completed in November. The topology for T3 ENSS backup is illustrated in a postscript map that is available via anonymous FTP on ftp.ans.net in the file . We have begun to work on subsequent optimizations to further improve backup connectivity. There may be situations where a secondary ENSS router is used to terminate T1 backup circuits. T1 Backbone Turned Off ---------------------- These activities required to precede the T1 backbone were concluded on 12/1 and the shutdown of the T1 backbone commenced on 12/2. There were a couple of problems that were quickly corrected during the T1 backbone shutdown. Some regionals that maintained default routing configurations pointing to the T1 backbone lost connectivity for a brief period. Some regional router configurations were changed, and the T3 backbone will continue to announce the T1 backbone address (129.140) from several ENSS nodes for a while longer to ease the transition. Also, there was a problem discovered with the RCP nodes in the "NSS-router" configuration used for the CA*Net interconnection to the T3 network. The RCPs could not manage the full 6000+ network destination routing tables. As a workaround, the three NSS-routers are now configured to advertise the T3 backbone network as a default route to CA*Net. ANSNET/NSFNET Operational Experiences with MBONE ================================================ During the week of 11/9 and 11/16, there were a number of operational problems during the preparation and actual operation of the IETF MBONE packet video/audiocast. The use of loose source route packets, and the large volume of MBONE traffic appears to have caused fairly widespread problems for several Internet service providers. However, the volume of MBONE traffic and source route optioned packets did not seem to adversely affect the ANSNET/NSFNET, as was earlier believed. There were severe routing Cooper [Page 42] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 instabilities with peer networks at several ANSNET/NSFNET border gateways including E128 (Palo Alto), E144 (FIX-E), E145 (FIX-W) and most notably at E133 (Ithaca) due to the MBONE traffic and processing of source route packets. The instability in these peer networks coupled with inefficient handling of very large and frequent routing changes introduced through EGP resulted in some ANSNET/NSFNET instabilities. Networks carrying MBONE traffic frequently stopped being advertised by external peers, and were timed out by the ENSS. The external peer then stabilized and these networks were then advertised to the ENSS by the external peer soon thereafter. This process repeated itself in a cyclical fashion. This caused a few connectivity problems at various places on the ANSNET, but was by far the worst at ENSS133 (Ithaca). One reason that the problem was worse at ENSS133 than at other places was due to the fact that Cornell was on the sending end of a fair number of MBONE tunnels, which meant the card-to-system traffic for unreachable destinations tended to be higher on the ENSS133 router than elsewhere. There were several actions taken during the week of 11/16 (IETF video/audiocast) which reduced the severity of this problem including: (a) ICMP unreachable messages were turned off on the external interfaces of ENSS routers that experienced problems. These messages were not being processed directly on the external ENSS interfaces which resulted in some inefficiency. New software will be deployed in early December to correct this. (b) SprintLink rerouted traffic (and the MBONE tunnel) from the IETF to Cornell from the CIX (via internal PSInet path), to the T3 ANSNET path. This improved stability within PSInet and within ANSNET. (c) Cornell rerouted traffic (MBONE tunnel) to SDSC from the PSInet path to the T3 ANSNET path. (d) One of the two parallel IETF audio/video channels was disabled. (e) A default route was established on ENSS133 pointing to its adjacent internal router (CNSS49). This ensured that card<->system traffic being processed due to unreachable destinations was moved to the CNSS router which was not involved in processing EGP updates. (f) A new version of the routing software was installed on the four ENSS nodes that experienced route flapping to aggregate EGP updates from external peers before sending IBGP messages Cooper [Page 43] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 to other internal T3 routers. The combination of all of these actions stabilized ENSS133 and the other ENSS routers that experienced instabilities. There are several actions which we already have, or will soon implement to avoid ANSNET border router instabilities during future MBONE multicast events: (1) The ENSS EGP software has been enhanced to support improved aggregation of updates from external peers into IBGP update messages. The ENSS will now aggregate EGP derived routes together into a single update before flooding this to other routers across the backbone via IBGP. This improves the efficiency of the ENSS dramatically. (2) A change to the ANSNET router interface microcode has been implemented (and will be deployed during early December) so that problems resulting from large amounts of ENSS card-system traffic will be eliminated when destinations become unreachable. Even if mrouted keeps sending traffic, this will be dropped on the incoming ENSS interface. (3) The T1 NSFNET backbone was disconnected on 12/2. The T1 network (particularly the interconnect points with the T3 system) was a major source of route flapping, and eliminating it should provide an additional margin for handling instability from other peer networks. While the changes we are making to the T3 network will significantly improve T3 network performance in dealing with external EGP peer flapping, and related MBONE routing problems, our changes will *NOT* improve the problems that other Internet networks may experience when processing source route packets, and handling routing transitions with MBONE tunnels. We recommend that each service provider develop their own internal routing plan to address this, we continue to recommend the migration to use of BGP at all border gateways, and we recommend that MBONE software be upgraded to support IP encapsulation to avoid the problems with routers that do not process loose source route optioned packets efficiently. We also are recommending that the MBONE developers explore optimizing the mrouted software to avoid the sustained unidirectional flows to unreachable destinations that we observed. Finally, it is recommended that an mrouted machine be maintained on the ENSS DMZ of each participating regional, and this node be used as a hierarchical distribution point to locations in the local campus and regional. Backhauling of traffic across campuses and regionals should be discouraged. Cooper [Page 44] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Routing Software on the T3 Network ================================== New routing software was installed on the T3 backbone in November to support various enhancements. There is improved route download performance using asynchronous IOCTL calls. There is new support for static routes, and checks for the size of BGP updates and attributes. New software will be installed in early December that addresses the routing instability problems observed during the MBONE multicast events in November. This will include the code for improved aggregation of EGP updates thereby eliminating any CPU starvation during EGP route flapping. Next AIX 3.1 System Software Release ==================================== New RS6000 system software was deployed on several T3 network nodes in late November and will be fully deployed by early December. The most significant change is the ability to drop packets on the interface which receives them for which there is no route available. During transient routing conditions we may experience high card/system traffic due to route downloads which can cause transient instabilities. This change will improve the efficiency for route installs/deletes between router system memory and the on-card forwarding tables. This code also supports the generation of ICMP network unreachable messages on the card rather than on the system. There are two bug fixes in this software, one for the performance problem that can occur when an IBGP TCP session gets deadlocked, and another that avoids FDDI problems if a T1 backup link on a T3 ENSS gets congested. Also all ENSS interfaces now support MTU path discovery. RS960 FDDI Deployment Status ============================ We are proceeding to schedule RS960 FDDI adapter installations on several ENSS nodes in December including ENSS134 (NEARnet), ENSS130 (Argonne), ENSS145 (FIX-E), ENSS136 (SURAnet), ENSS139 (SESQUInet), ENSS144 (FIX-W), ENSS142 (WestNet), and ENSS143 (NorthWestNet). There are performance tests under way involving Pittsburgh Supercomputer Center, San Diego Supercomputer Center, and National Center for Supercomputer Applications that are designed to exploit the FDDI high bandwidth capability. The MTUs on various interfaces in the T3 backbone have been changed as was described in the October engineering report, and the ENSS nodes will negotiate MTU Cooper [Page 45] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 path discovery with other systems outside the T3 backbone. During the tests performed so far, there have been some observations of low level packet loss (1.6%) between the Cray end systems at the supercomputer centers which has caused performance problems with the large window TCP implementations achieving peak performance over the T3 backbone. The packet loss problems have not been traced to sources inside the T3 backbone, and the problem is being investigated by the supercomputer centers. Network Source/Destination Statistics Collection ================================================ During November, we collected the first full month of T3 network source/destination traffic statistics. This data will be used for topology engineering, capacity planning, and various research projects. RS960 Memory Parity Problem =========================== During November, we experienced two problems on CNSS17 and CNSS65 due to the failure of parity checking logic within the on-card memory on selected RS960 T3 adapters. These outages are very infrequent and do not generally result in ENSS isolation from the network since only a single interface will be affected, and redundant connectivity is employed on other CNSS interfaces. The problems were cleared by a software reset of the interface. The problem is suspected to be due to the memory technology used on some of the cards. Jordan Becker (becker@ans.net) Mark Knopper (mak@merit.edu) NSFNET/INFORMATION SERVICES --------------------------- The Network Services Conference 1992, organized by EARN, EUnet/EurOpen, NORDUnet, RARE and RIPE, convened in Pisa, Italy in early November. Ellen Hoffman, manager of Merit Information Services, traveled to Pisa and presented an overview of Internet uses at this international gathering. Pat Smith of Merit/NSFNET Information Services hosted Merit's "Cruise of the Internet" in a workshop at the ACM SIGUCCS User Services Conference held in Cleveland, Ohio. Other members of the Merit Information Services staff took the helm of the Cruise in national and MichNet regional activities: Mark Davis-Craig spoke to members of Penn Link at Penn State University and to attendees of the library dedication program at Baker College, Flint, MI; Laura Kelleher "cruised" with the Cooper [Page 46] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Michigan Association for Computer Users in Learning (MACUL) at their conference, "Computer Networking in Education." The IETF program in Washington, D.C. had the active participation of several Merit staff members: working group chairs and co-chairs include Hoffman of Userdoc2, Smith of NISI, Mark Knopper (manager Merit Internet Engineering) of TUBA, Sue Hares (Internet Engineering) of NOOP, and Chris Weider (IS Information Delivery Systems) of DISI and the newly chartered Integration of Internet Information Resources working group (IIIR). Weider also led discussions on index services and Whois++. A BOF on training materials was co-chaired by Hoffman, and Kelleher was among the participants in this session. Also attending IETF programs from Merit were Richard Schmalgemeier, Elise Gerich, John Scudder, Bill Norton, Larry Blunk and Al Rubens. The Coalition for Networked Information (CNI) also met in Washington, D.C., with Ellen Hoffman, Laura Kelleher and Chris Weider attending on behalf of Merit. Kelleher presented an update on the Top Node Project, a CNI sponsored endeavor at Merit and the University of Indiana. Weider, Kelleher and Hoffman are involved in the ongoing initiative to integrate MARC records with the current IAFA standards in Top Node. Eric Aupperle, President of Merit Network, Inc. participated in a panel discussion at the 6th Annual Next Generation Networks Conference in Washington, D.C. Sue Hares was Merit's representative to the ANSI X353.3 meeting in Boston, MA. A new subdirectory, /nsf.agreements, is available under the /nsfnet directory on the host nic.merit.edu. This directory contains correspondence between Merit Network, Inc. and the National Science Foundation regarding issues and policies of the NSFNET: agreement on the flow of commercial traffic across NSF sponsored gateways to the T3 network, technical compliance, and cost recoveries and disbursement for the use of the shared infrastructure. These files are available for Anonymous FTP from nic.merit.edu or via an electronic mail message to: nis-info@nic.merit.edu with the first line of text (not the subject) as send filename With the implementation of a new statistical sampling program on the T3 backbone in early November, byte and packet traffic by network are available for Anonymous FTP from nic.merit.edu in the directory /nsfnet/statistics/1992. NSFNET T3 Traffic Distribution Cooper [Page 47] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Highlights, /nsfnet/statistics/1992/t3-9211.highlights, identifies the most commonly occurring services, and other selected services. A comprehensive survey of NSFNET T3 traffic distribution by service is available in /nsfnet/statistics/1992/t3-9211.ports. Jo Ann Ward (jward@merit.edu) PREPNET ------- PREPnet: 305 South Craig Street, 2nd Fl. Pittsburgh, PA 15213-3706 412-268-7870 fax: 412-268-7875 prepnet+@andrew.cmu.edu The following have joined PREPnet since October 1, 1992: In Pittsburgh Union Switch and Signal, Inc. will connect at 56K, and The Pittsburgh Energy Technology Center will have a T1 connection. VVimaging, Inc. has a T1 conection to the State College hub. The Franklin Institute Science Museum is connected in Philadelphia at T1. The Pennsylvania Geological Survey will connect to the Harrisburg hub ate 56K. PREPnet is currently engaged in an SMDS demo in cooperation with Bell of PA. The demo is based in Pittsburgh and connects four members/affiliates: Carnegie Mellon University, The Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center, IBM Industrial Technology Center, and Shadyside Hospital. The demo began on September 1st and will continue through January 1993. During the demo, we will test the capacity and performace of the SMDS switch. On October 2nd, Steve Vogelsang gave a short demonstration of the Internet at the Instructional Material Services meeting in Pittsburgh. Steve also provided training for United States Steel in Pittsburgh on October 22nd. Marsha Perrott attended the November IETF meeting in Washington D.C. PREPnet NIC (prepnet+@andrew.cmu.edu) Cooper [Page 48] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 SDSC (SAN DIEGO SUPERCOMPUTER CENTER) ------------------------------------- SDSC Network Activities ======================= The major activity for the month was the splitting of our main building Ethernet into multiple segments and the resulting need to reconfigure every device in the building to handle their new address and subnet mask. This was done over the weekend of 20-22 Nov. The ripples took several more days to damp out. All this planned to happen when we placed our new Auspex file server into production use. Our next Flag day will be during the end of year hoildays when we plan to convert our DMZ from a subnet of 132.249 to a Class C. SDSC Applied Network Research Group =================================== Study of Routing Fluctuations Bilal Chinoy completed a study of routing fluctuations as seen by the NSFNET backbone and quantified the changes in terms of the number of networks changing state, time intervals between state changes, average number of transitions per network, etc. The results should be available soon in the form of a technical paper. Packet Video We received a test version of the IBM person-to person packet video conferencing system from IBM. We plan to study the system and characterize it's end-to-end performance when used across the Internet. Initial cross-country experiments have started at this point of time. Backbone Traffic Characterization As a followup to our May 1992 study of the T1 NSFNET backbone, this month we have begun to investigate the packet characterization statistics for the T3 backbone, with help from Merit and ANS. The recent deployment of statistics collection functionality in the T3 routers, and the helpful cooperation of the developers of that software (at Merit and ANS) are facilitating our study. Cooper [Page 49] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 Travel ====== Paul Love attended the IETF meeting held in Washington, DC. by Paul Love UCL ---- 1. We now have 3 GPT Codecs cponnected via HSI/S boards to suns, and are able to capture video from them at 192kbps and exchange it over TCP and UDP (multicast). We are working on inter-working tests between these, some BT Codecs and the Inria IVS H.261 software. This entails stripping out the H.221 framing (one of the more stupid protocols in existence), and enhancing IVS to discard or use motion vectors. We are currently using a delay adaptation scheme for receiving H.261 over TCP connections that operates rather lkike the Vat audio one. This seems to work ok, so long as TCP does not apply the congesiton avoidance window after loss. The receiver specifies a tolerable delay, and if this exceeds one RTT by more than a RTT variance, we can tolerate retransmits. If not, we just adapt to delay variation. 2. The MICE project (prematurely announced last month) is now officially underway. 3. The SuperJANET project now has a contracted supplier (BT, as has been announced in the press). Initially, they will provide up to 45 sites with 34 Mbps SMDS access as well as 6 (increasing to 12) sites with 140 Mbps PHDH access for pilot ATM and higher speed network research. This will transition to SDH throughout, with an ATM overlay. Initial pilot projects will be up by March 1993, ranging from applications (viscous fingering and remote video teaching of surgery) to interworking of ATM switches. For more details on the Superjanet project, please mail: janet- liason-desk@jnt.ac.uk - for copies of Network News Numner 38 which covers the announcement. atm@jnt.ac.uk - for UK ATM discussion John Crowcroft (j.crowcroft@CS.UCL.AC.UK) Cooper [Page 50] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 WISCNET ------- The Medical College of Wisconsin and the University of Wisconsin - Parkside connections will be upgraded from 56K DDS to T1 SMDS service through the Wiscnet hub at the University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee. Ameritech Advanced Data Systems will supply the SMDS service and DSUs. The upgrade is expected to be completed by the end of January '93. Michael Dorl (dorl@vms.macc.wisc.edu) Cooper [Page 51] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 CALENDAR -------- Readers are requested to send in dates of events that are appropriate for this calendar section. Please send your submissions to (cooper@isi.edu). 1992 CALENDAR Nov 29 T1E1, Anaheim, CA Dec 6-9 GLOBECOM '92, Orlando, Florida (See IEE Pub.) Dec 7-11 DECUS '92, Las Vegas, NV Dec 13 T1AG Dec 14-18 OIW, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD Dec 18 ECTUA General Assembly, 1993 CALENDAR Jan RARE Council of Administration, TBC Jan 4-7 Intl Workshop on Intelligent, Jan 5-7 ANSI X3S3.3, Menlo Park, Ca Jan 11-15 TCOS WG, New Orleans Jan 25-27 RIPE, Prague Jan 25-29 USENIX, San Diego Feb 1-5 ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6/WG3 and WG6, London Feb 8-12 ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6/WG1 and WG4, London Feb 11-12 PSRG Workshop on Network and Distributed System Security, San Diego, Ca Feb 28-Mar 3 Modeling & Analysis of Telecommunication Systems, Nashville, TN Mar 8-12 INTEROP93, Wasington, D.C. Dan Lynch (dlynch@interop.com) Mar 8-12 OIW, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD Mar 15-18 Uniform, San Francisco Mar 24-31 CEBIT 93, Hannover, Germany Mar 29 - Apr 2, IETF, Columbus, Ohio Apr 5-19 TCOS WG, Boston (tentative) Apr 14-16 National Net'93, Washington, D.C. (net93@educom.edu) Apr 18-23 IFIP WG 6.6 Third International Symposium on Integrated Network Management, Sheraton Palace Hotel, San Francisco, CA (kzm@hls.com) Apr 20-22 ANSI X3S3.3, Orlando, FL May 10-13 4th Joint European Networking COnf., JENC93 Trondheim, Norway May 13-14 RARE Council of Administration, Trondheim May 23-26 ICC'93, Geneva, Switzerland Cooper [Page 52] Internet Monthly Report November 1992 May-Jun PSTV-XIII, University of Liege. Contact: Andre Danthine, Jun 2-4 ANSI X3S3.3, Raleigh, NC Jun 7-11 OIW, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD Jun 15-30 ISO/IEC JTC1/SC21, Yokohama Jun 21-25 USENIX, Cincinnati Jun 30 RARE Technical Committee, Amsterdam Jul IETF, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Jul 12-16 TCOS WG, Hawaii (tentative) Aug 1-6 Multimedia '93, Anaheim, CA Aug 17-20 INET '93, San Franc, CA (inet93@educom.edu) Aug 18-21 INET93, San Francisco Bay Area Aug 23-27 INTEROP93, San Francisco Dan Lynch (dlynch@interop.com) Aug SIGCOMM 93, San Francisco Sep ?? 6th SDL Forum, Darmstadt Ove Faergemand (ove@tfl.dk) Sep 8-9 ANSI X3S3.3, Boulder, CO Sep 13-17 OIW, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD Sep 20-31 ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6, Seoul, Korea. Sep 28-29 September RIPE Technical Days, TBC Sep 30-Oct 2 Paris Oct INTEROP93, Paris, France Oct 12-14 Conference on Network Information Processing, Sofia, Bulgaria; Contact: IFIP-TC6 Oct 18-22 TCOS WG, Atlanta, GA (tentative) Nov 2-4 ANSI X3S3.3, TBD Nov 9-13 IEEE802 Plenary, LaJolla, CA Nov 15-19 Supercomputing 93, Portland, OR Dec 6-10 OIW, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD 1994 CALENDAR Apr 18-22 INTEROP94, Washington, D.C. Dan Lynch (dlynch@interop.com) Jun 1-3 IFIP WG 6.5 ULPAA, Barcelona, Spain Einar Stefferud (stef@nma.com) Aug 29-Sep 2 IFIP World Congress Hamburg, Germany; Contact: IFIP Sep 12-16 INTEROP94, San Francisco Dan Lynch (dlynch@interop.com) 1995 CALENDAR Sep 18-22 INTEROP95, San Francisco, CA Dan Lynch (dlynch@interop.com) ======================================================================== Cooper [Page 53] Presently we were in a very dark road, and at a point where it dropped suddenly between steep sides we halted in black shadow. A gleam of pale sand, a whisper of deep flowing waters, and a farther glimmer of more sands beyond them challenged our advance. We had come to a "grapevine ferry." The scow was on the other side, the water too shoal for the horses to swim, and the bottom, most likely, quicksand. Out of the blackness of the opposite shore came a soft, high-pitched, quavering, long-drawn, smothered moan of woe, the call of that snivelling little sinner the screech-owl. Ferry murmured to me to answer it and I sent the same faint horror-stricken tremolo back. Again it came to us, from not farther than one might toss his cap, and I followed Ferry down to the water's edge. The grapevine guy swayed at our side, we heard the scow slide from the sands, and in a few moments, moved by two videttes, it touched our shore. Soon we were across, the two videttes riding with us, and beyond a sharp rise, in an old opening made by the swoop of a hurricane, we entered the silent unlighted bivouac of Ferry's scouts. Ferry got down and sat on the earth talking with Quinn, while the sergeants quietly roused the sleepers to horse. Plotinus is driven by this perplexity to reconsider the whole theory of Matter.477 He takes Aristotle¡¯s doctrine as the groundwork of his investigation. According to this, all existence is divided into Matter and Form. What we know of things¡ªin other words, the sum of their differential characteristics¡ªis their Form. Take away this, and the unknowable residuum is their Matter. Again, Matter is the vague indeterminate something out of which particular Forms are developed. The two are related as Possibility to Actuality, as the more generic to the more specific substance through every grade of classification and composition. Thus there are two Matters, the one sensible and the other intelligible. The former constitutes the common substratum of bodies, the other the common element of ideas.478 The general distinction between Matter and Form was originally suggested to Aristotle by Plato¡¯s remarks on the same subject; but he differs325 from his master in two important particulars. Plato, in his Timaeus, seems to identify Matter with space.479 So far, it is a much more positive conception than the ?λη of the Metaphysics. On the other hand, he constantly opposes it to reality as something non-existent; and he at least implies that it is opposed to absolute good as a principle of absolute evil.480 Thus while the Aristotelian world is formed by the development of Power into Actuality, the Platonic world is composed by the union of Being and not-Being, of the Same and the Different, of the One and the Many, of the Limit and the Unlimited, of Good and Evil, in varying proportions with each other. The Lawton woman had heard of an officer's family at Grant, which was in need of a cook, and had gone there. [See larger version] On the 8th of July an extraordinary Privy Council was summoned. All the members, of whatever party, were desired to attend, and many were the speculations as to the object of their meeting. The general notion was that it involved the continuing or the ending of the war. It turned out to be for the announcement of the king's intended marriage. The lady selected was Charlotte, the second sister of the Duke of Mecklenburg-Strelitz. Apart from the narrowness of her education, the young princess had a considerable amount of amiability, good sense, and domestic taste. These she shared with her intended husband, and whilst they made the royal couple always retiring, at the same time they caused them to give, during their lives, a moral air to their court. On the 8th of September Charlotte arrived at St. James's, and that afternoon the marriage took place, the ceremony being performed by the Archbishop of Canterbury. On the 22nd the coronation took place with the greatest splendour. Mother and girls were inconsolable, for each had something that they were sure "Si would like," and would "do him good," but they knew Josiah Klegg, Sr., well enough to understand what was the condition when he had once made up his mind. CHAPTER V. THE YOUNG RECRUITS Si proceeded to deftly construct a litter out of the two guns, with some sticks that he cut with a knife, and bound with pawpaw strips. His voice had sunk very low, almost to sweetness. A soft flurry of pink went over her face, and her eyelids drooped. Then suddenly she braced herself, pulled herself taut, grew combative again, though her voice shook. HoME²Ô¾®Ïè̫ʲôÐÇ×ù ENTER NUMBET 0016www.fzchain.com.cn
www.mgwfge.com.cn
izkgqx.com.cn
gzyhncp.org.cn
www.kokwz.com.cn
herocean.com.cn
www.ubbxec.com.cn
www.nyqqdr.com.cn
www.vz38.org.cn
www.wnchain.com.cn
中文字幕的h电影 xiao 色网 美国女性裸体图片网 最新的成人网站网址 雷丝兔宝宝更新50p 露男人下体的黄色a片有哪些 如月群真贴吧福利图 骚妹影院删除 黑山三高中孟璐 欧美写真在线视频 老色狗网站 父女乱伦纯肉文 八匹狼资源站 屄掰女 操逼都有那电视剧 www三级片cnm 我爱逼另类小说 我和隔壁阿姨黄色小说 人i与动物快播 苍井空【50p】 人与兽黄片视频一级片 耻体少妇 操美女尸体小说 ribennvrendeyindaoyouduochang 美国少女露鲍人体大胆艺术照 女人操屄图片 波多野结衣内射中出快播播放 你的屄毛 摩悦菁艺上海电子有限公司 激情小说美女色图 h幼女小说txt 我爱大学生无码迅雷下载 排球女将24rmvb 欧美女人醉酒露出图片 90后性a网 女性人体艺术狠撸 禄草裙社区 美国拍av的明星 迷奸媳妇舔食淫液小说 WWW_49223_COM 日本空姐被操视频 裸摸骚逼 百度爬灰小说老卫和儿媳 潮吹女王30p 偷拍电影伦理片 西西欧美美女大胆秀人体艺术 3000人体摄影艺术 操幼女小驻逼小说 妹の秘密种子下载 WWW_OMBYY_COM 自拍视频2 我和嫂子的做爱故事 WWW_6186 骚货颜射 美女穴穴高清图片 鸡爸巴插逼视频 三级片黄片做爱片 欧美做爱图片20p 美女淫荡性交图片 色狂い8人娘 木村真理惠 电影 8844ddd 干肉丝袜少妇 爆肏女明星 亚洲 套图 偷拍 WWW_UESSS_COM 欧美美女内衣写真真集 爱贝导航 绿妈文同好交流社区 围城读后感 白酒招商政策 吴苇珊 taijong 香港古装三级bt 掰开蜜穴 av9cc 天涯导航色 快播播放器的黄色网站 男生女生在床糟逼电影 五月天色网偷拍自拍 女人爱操逼怎么办 我与男同事的性爱 三级色色色色网 操逼有害不可大力日比 有什么好看的成人电影网 多淫荡少妇15p segif 鸭哥哥yx日本 明星色巴 影音先锋日本av女优妹妹电影 性感明星大尺度艳照 gayjiaonu 中国肥女人人体 撸一撸6666 伊在爱商城成人色爱 治阳瘘早泄的中药泡酒 色狠久撸啊撸小说 wwwsqo 姐姐图片穴 霪霪网在线视频免费 日本av毛片迅雷种子 变态图区911色色色 美女清纯性撸图 佐藤吉吉影音 黑人狂操亚裔女 heisiyouwu 成人做爱动态视频 色亚小说 夜色视频免费观看20 欧美性交第一会所 伦乱透屄故事 WWW190JCOM 操姨妈导航 西西色老头人体艺术 婶婶你真骚 哥哥干手机小说 美国sex网站导航 日本av三级文学 朋友妈妈巨乳诱惑快播 插骚逼屁眼 876αv电影 WWWANGOULECOM 鸭妹妹子网址 日本落体做爰图片 neishesaoxue ed2k国产熟女 床上草视频 少妇爱爱撸 迅雷在线激情乱伦 刘亦菲合成15p 美女光定身体图片 六六床戏 抽插穴屌流 WWWJNVCOMTLBFE 黄色小说片子 激激色 成人最猛网站视频 寂寞少妇的诱惑最新章节 男主角20年后与女主角重遇的欧美电影 十次啦美国小说 大鸡巴香烟价格 欧美超模被操 WWW66MMDDCOM 少妇挤奶50p 骚女大姨妈来了16p 午夜三级小说快播 亚洲少女性图 张柏芝loub 555电影三级2013118 zooskool经典系列 苍井空ed2k华为 国产母狗 打炮口活美女3g 狠狠碰xxoo成人电影免播放器在线观看 人体模特小游 媳妇浪穴 男人为什么喜欢吃女人逼逼 先锋影院在线观看 幼女养成h文 823824 看性感动漫 这个被操的嗷嗷叫爱色网 成人图片漏图 馒头逼吧 非洲大阴蒂 我爱和老女人做爱 东南亚少女10p 曰本为什么喜欢拍成人片 大美女的鲍鱼被狂插 美女裸体图片欧美色图2010 5252avi xiaoshuocao 百度大尺度美女图片 一起看吧动感之星影音先锋 小孩草大人的小说 色色小说综合 最猛成人网站 ziweiqun 百合纯肉真人电影 优希麻琴女教师 婷婷五月香基地 欧美性爱制度诱惑另类图片 圣诞老人射小妞和强奸小妞动话片 成人世界摸摸你 哥要蝴蝶谷娱乐中文网 日本三级艳星人体艺术 爆乳母娘仙桃影视网 欧美性爱色图网站 色涩黑木耳 韩国美女插洞 xxoo网av在线视频男人天堂 www294caocommsequ1co 欧美骚逼网 夜射狼AV亚洲在线视频 贵阳成人国产自拍 李毅情趣小说 fatgirlchineseav 操姐姐娱乐 欧美人体校园 五月激情乱伦小说网 王者荣耀cosplayav 人妻的淫逼 十大中字无码动漫名字 在线福利社天龙八部 做爱揉捏抽插三级图片 男少年同性插屁眼小说 930影城色色影城 手机看成人动作大片 野猪网俄罗斯理论电影 农村tongjian 表姐穆婷婷 pp55牛叉B电影 2017伦理中文字幕剧情 图解李宗瑞艳照 成人激情运动 色偷偷成人资源站 bqq477看av群 台湾淫荡老婆 优优影视www44pecomwwwseqingyouyou285621cc 插嫩嫩的护士10pwww5zipaicom 加勒比ad 短篇剧情网站 zzz76zycom 现代激情校园春色html 蔡依林邪恶小说 动漫亚洲强奸乱伦magnet porn家教 狠狠操妈妈的穴 亚洲成人网站做爱小视频 wwwdphzrnetcn 94yrocm 妈妈供我上学14利群 印度美女坐脸 韩国肏屄magnet 日韩新片网成人动漫 亚里沙综合 360自拍偷拍自慰小视频 百度厕所偷拍在线视频 西西阴陪人体艺术 性感美女风骚丝袜子 淫乱妈妈王的母亲节 乱伦小说调教性奴表姐 港台bt 人妖超碰XXOO免费视频 绝美学生妹课间女主 p8成人电影网站免费 kaori养母轮奸 黄色电影在哪里获得 人妻武侠第1页 www502日本少妇com 强奸美女秘书黄色小说 爆操美女吉吉 经典有声插插中和网 爱福利撸wwwfulilubacom av办公室ol AV美丽川mxiaomemecom 日本wwwsao 操嫩15p成人 aog里番 找幼破身小说 美女女性交图片 人体裸体metcn庄媛 原沙奈央 捆绑系列20p 和女同事激情做爱 xxoo波多野结衣 松本美影片 幼女性交体会 wwwx32bcxv 大胆人体嫩穴艺术摄影 操嫂子肉逼 就爱大片网的网址 爱我多深ipad在线看 不卡的av52 www999xbxbcom 成熟少妇图片 先锋免费成年电影 超碰四虎网站 AVcooavmoocom 性爱区在现看 龙口门影音先锋在线看 日本女被深喉15P 孙女在厨房内射 狼国48Q 上了白虎姐姐 wwwepornercom 色图动图 激淫15p wwwav三级 人妖丝袜美臀 3P书屋 手机新域名ady手机看片 熟女30pdizhi 水菜丽scute在线 2017狠狠撸最新网址 插b免费视频 姐妹监禁教师 欧美gv下载 WWWSAO117COM 口述我和妹妹的欲望 swwwporndigcom 丝袜姜女操动态图 222bob 翁媳操逼乱伦 男同志AV在线 淫荡明星在线 女生把男生的肉棒放到嘴里 素人妻第1页伦理电影在线观看伦理电影网站伦理聚合 女优舌头舔屏幕av 18福利影院 91视频AV 1238100有毒吗 青青草女用道具在线视频 超碰av免费视频超在线wwwcao077com 伦理片安乐战场 黑人操社区影院导航 志村玲子手机在线观看 激情五月色视频www031ncom 免费看天天A片美女图片免费 1333ccc Wwwdidi319com 精品50p www53cccc 小学生AV910ppcom 色色射撸 偷拍厕所台湾妹中文 wwwsss258com 老淑女逼毛视频 现代激情人妻乱伦 最新热情网页 www路bu780 老婆出轨了搞她比以前水多了 色师傅按摩 东方在线50o 阴蒂小电影 操荔 在线青青视频免费观 色系x小说 99视频久久热视频 乱伦乱奸 亚卅av在线视频 啪啪小说阅读 韩国情侣做爱高清自拍看巨乳多多影音 淫荡乱伦图区 av在线网址l 撸管视频网 女厕拍2014视频 35aaacorn 我爱大咪咪黄片 www89bbecon下载 在洗澡的时候做爱 插逼穴图片 伦理吃奶小说 国产sss视频在线 人妻乱抡小说 97色播五月 大阴茎插进小舅妈 大机巴饶了我吧视频 97122997WYTXXX87627EEEcom 玩弄女星破处 xvideosgratistv另类变态 亚洲变态另类色图天堂网 五月天色色新版图片 熟女乱伦先锋影音 亚洲0xox 色色色色色射射 www色cam 印度成人色图 超碰网址发布野 奸插干网站 omeixingaishicila 姐姐被我插屄 有一个裸聊的直播网页 催情药调教美妇 wwww色五月C0m 偷啪i 搞AV自拍图 xfplay自拍 日本丝袜无码影音先锋播放 淫淫孩子 嫩逼穴成人美女 998zyzco钬唌 色狼色哥哥色姐姐 在线妻子乱轮偷情 欧美辣图沾花网 爽爽在线ab 操妹妹国产 成人嘿咻嘿咻网 深夜福利在线看天上人 老婆卖淫小说 吸白嫩的女人 影音在线久久草 内射学生幼幼 wwwky757com为什么看不了 插插插综合小说网comwwwssss88com 人妻女友之撸撸 日少妇av 肉棒抽查操干图片 慢慢射亚洲色图 nnyythunder 影音先锋网制服丝袜 乱伦阿姨AV在线 两个男人一起自慰 免插件高清合集 大鸡巴用力操激情性爱 很骚的MⅤ 魔王在线iav99 好看站手机站版 双插另类 欧美一级黄色大片 噜噜哭 成人网站成人色图成人视频 色罗莉怎么看不了了 操已婚情人在线视频 闹洞房就去干 野外性交xxxx 欧美女人潮吹视频在线观看 酒色哥我爱撸 少妇 熟女 聚会 生活照自拍 照片 丰满 性感 皇瑟luan lun 成人色视频网 换妻俱乐部4p无码照片 小草影视龚iue菲新金瓶电影先锋 校园春色乱轮 网盘下载 国产a片 狗骚女 强叉美女小穴 无马欧美 张筱雨人体去术精选 丝袜妹妹求我插 女孩 做爱 自拍 几月采阴陈 时间暂停器全套12部 乱伦小说女婿与丈母娘 长筒袜做爱图片 骚屄3p 少妇巨乳诱惑影音先锋 夜夜斎颂逡帐? 全祼体女张筱雨 四房色播五月天色小姐 最新肥胖人体艺术摄影 仓井空巨乳女教师 强根宝有没有用 插大奶胖逼 兽交片小说 0809嫩逼导航 肉丝少妇狠狠撸 农村淫乱做爱 d2e487f00000079f 操淫荡小姨子 自拍操穴 美女最大胆裸体艺术写真 影音先锋溜冰影院 插阴道人体艺术大图大全 帕丽斯希尔顿哈佛一夜性爱录象带影音先锋 动物jiao 淫荡诛仙 熟妇中出哥哥射俺去撸 姬岛琉璃种子 少妇粉红鲍鱼穴 韩国女主播之香淑影音先锋 女教师与学生性交网盘 第一会所亚洲无码熟女 韩国裸体性交 26uuu图片 能播放的欧美群交视频 咸色小说 幼逼百图 全裸掰开逼逼大尺度人体艺术 日本动作片 百度网盘 求大奶大屁股的视频 迷奸迷奸快播电影免费欣赏 国语对白影音先锋手机 成人性生活网址 轮里涩涩 实况足球8补丁 全职猎人348 卡索 高清沟厕偷拍 熟女先锋 30p亚洲性交 黑人草亚洲美女大鸡巴 美女美女我要插逼逼18p 偸拍野站视频 全裸日本充气娃娃照片 老女人露脸口交哥必撸 tubi8中国三级 人体艺术芭离 老师孙老头看看你的内部拍的照片 色妹妹丁香社区妞妞 善良的美人妇加强版20 现代女性性交大全 依人22成人综合网 五码视频在线观看 xxxxppppus社区 撸撸管图片 悠悠人体写真艺术 小男孩以妈妈性交视频 WWWCCC212COM 华人色小说 强奸学校学生亚洲图片 女友穿情趣内衣让我操她 qingchunmeinvpeike 人体全裸艺术美女 顶级人体艺术欧美人体艺术 性感丝袜美女图库欧美色图欧美色图 日本母子l乱伦中文字幕 哪里有美貌女子们的性隐私迅雷下载地址 哪里a片视频 零疼痛人体正确使用姿势书 WWWHNYTWLCOM WWWNTLIDUCOM 我和秦青的性福 佐藤穗乃花 少女和爷爷性交 肏丈母娘屁眼 骚妇掰屄图片 正在播放五十路母影音播放 国模莎莎美乳少妇掰开肥鲍露出湿润大尺度私拍 我插的美女好爽啊无约定香甜 吉吉影音无码艳舞 谁有日本美女黄色照网址 svssex 女模爱爱图 百度美女裸体艺术作品 日逼的网站 鸭哥哥影视 男动物色平色 大学生淫荡做爱 美女私处超大胆高清人体艺术图片摄影3 性爱真人自拍 操屄小说视频 大色窝基地之大色鸟 蒙古女人的性欲故事 老人操逼做爱图片 黄色三色片伦理网 亚洲扒衣 激情网站丁香五月狠狠咂色视频 无毒网站北岛玲 A1黄色片magnet 网友自拍情景剧儿子干妈妈 录音精品线播放 妻子与干爹李娜TXT 肛交av网站 青青草冷sm视频 手机看视频不支持s 欧美性爱色尼古 欧美唆鸡巴 43脳ecom 免费片第一次 丰满肉欲少妇p 儿子插完妈妈插妹妹 韩国赤裸做爱 春暖花开之Wc女厕所偷拍系列网站 紧急更新通知magnet 淫姐姐骗了弟弟操她逼 faxmagnet 意外插入妈妈的身体是那部av电影 制服丝袜亚洲艳舞写真影音 96插妹妹sexsex88com 天天拍天天操神马 人狗做爱过程 大炮影院手机在线观看 56人艺术摄影 帅男同的鸡鸡ed2k 苍井空色域迷强 百度久久做爱视频 插菊花综合网好吊日wwwfwy57trcom 美女俄罗妈妈女主 美性中文娱文网22 国产自拍影 人兽与美女xxoo的视频 教师情景日本A片视频 日你屄流水小说 久久撸人人操综合网站 大鸡吧插入妈妈骚逼 外国姨蕾丝水 狼老公吃老婆类奶子爸爸 淫乱鸳鸯 日韩美少女射精视频 高h肉文推荐 母淫网姐姐 色吧影院54occom 日本母子性爱游戏mp4 非非影视成 香港经典三级被动物插 非州大鸡巴淫色网 抽插艺术 撸撸网分类 看看a片国语a片国语 老婆自慰番号 亚洲2014性爱偷拍 深爱五月天丁香 se五月天有声小说 春色图宫 春色12街 春色文学 春色增大 樱井莉亚松岛枫 樱井莉亚美人 小泽玛利亚双通 www点w21w 开心五月天地址 酒色网的最新地址 哪里能看黄片 快播看黄片地址 求黄色小说网站 美女电影 丁香五月天 母息子影院 AV激情伦理 AV女优电影 色哥哥妹妹 新农夫 额尔撸 百度www·taobaoav 兔牙喵喵在线观看影院 经典三级 欧美无码 在线视频 白白让你操 俺去也网色 55we韩国主播 娃玖影院 4280影院 7m视频最最新版 免费剧情漫画 人人摸人操 李月华满清禁宫秘史 全国最大成人视频 裙子福利视频在线观看 亚洲AV AV在线 AV天堂 邪恶少漫画acg邪恶帝 翘臀美女后进式10p视频在线 强奸少妇花心在线视频 小黄视频免费观看在线播放 日本性虐式变态性交电影 日韩白丝护士足交 日本亚欧高情视频 日本一本道官方在线 日本无码老司机 日韩黄色大片 magnet 日本一本加比勒 400部韩国女主播视频 插萝莉影院 猫狗影视 小蛮腰xxmmyy 视频全集 亚洲百部 红楼影院tv 宾馆草肉丝美女 这女的喷奶好牛逼 西瓜影音 大香蕉喷奶 欧美色女郎 隔离老王免费国产在线av手机观看 wwwyese632 簊田在线观看网站 AV里面luxu什么意思 av人妻2015新人 椎名由奈会长 亚洲做好爱免费视频 狼友 国庆 福利 提示:点开黑屏或白屏缓冲五秒 [红包] 福利免费视频 [红包] ht 越南女人做爱视频dvd 下载 pp福利影院 澳门av视频福利 成人 国产偷拍综合福利门秒拍视频 色色的爱免费视屏 国产视频大佬色 免费 徐娘半老伦理片 在线视频执着高品质 咬奶头成人 xiunv225恋夜影院教师 依依亚洲图片去哪里 午马影院午夜 你懂百度资源 周晓琳大西瓜 日本69movies戴套 午夜不卡理论 98影院播在线 avbob官网下载 丁香六月激情 天然素人av面接加勒比 校园贷porn 刘嘉玲8分视频下载 ftp 影音先锋 松下纱荣子 9999撸一撸 广西主播西西 magnet 女仆装自拍美乳福利在线播放-国产自拍 - 怡红院 怡春院 怡红院电影 最爱怡红 女理发师番号 bkfuli影院 五月婷婷六月丁香综合基地 网站升级反问 avxfzy资源网 久久热漫画 男人大战人妻 XXXa片 800av福利视频导航 世界十大禁片 ftp 爱蜜莉灰毛衣三部曲迅雷下载 亚洲av欧美av电影av视频 五月天天堂电影 大香蕉福利小视频在线影院 夫妻影院 福利影院闪现福利 yinjiejieyinyuan 大陆 自拍 偷拍 国产 福利H 大奶美女做爱播放片 ye1378。com 偷拍,自拍AV伦理电影 国产 日韩 伦理聚合 3国产 自拍 欧美 性爱 日本无码日本有码亚洲 www999abaom 高h黄视频 风 月 海 棠 精 品 啪 啪 情 趣 黑 丝 套 装 美 少 妇 高清在线播放-华人-91爱爱 搞搞b电影网 俺播 秋霞微博连接i AV午夜福利手机直播在线观看 偷拍女生洗澡成人网站 4388网站鸭王 色女人偷拍 夜勤病栋橘子 猫咪 黄片 欧美a片磁力链接 magnet 终极监狱高清电影新闻 大乳美女秀美腿视频 国产自拍偷拍av 影音先锋 小湿影 美足vn 最新日韩性爱视频 黄片100不啪啪啪 3p自拍在线 日本成人动漫视频在线播放 一人一碰操视频 xxxchinese国产h自拍 avttnet天堂网2014 无码av在线av av天堂网2019 私人文件夹漫画 一级美容色国产 亚洲色农夫Av 东方影库av无码在线播放 竹内纱里奈诱惑美痴女 夜秀 迪丽热巴三部曲下载 美国午夜综艺节目大全 四虎视频茄子视频 黑人巨勃根 美女吃春药自慰视频 午夜視频,普通用户,邪恶38 月经期的黄色视频裸体交配 自拍偷拍 家庭乱 赵飞燕迅雷下载 下载 影音先锋乱伦强奸在线 se5xxx69 颜射口爆小女神 美女动态图张又黄又色 桃色电影磁力链接 香蕉网大人网 色欲影视狠狠插 任你一操 欧美怡红院大香焦 2青娱乐视频综合在线 苍井空无修50分钟在线 老色哥俺去也 神崎亜里沙 青娱乐755 国模人体蜈蚣 成长影院久久爱人人观看 阿v天堂在线CK 産婦人科 死刑囚 病院 操女人逼视频播放 铃原爱蜜莉在线 贵阳夫妇在线 私拍app 国产自拍第10页 日本r级2019电影在线看 小仙儿有声小说资源站 美国农夫新导航手机版 裸条贷款10g在线观看 佐佐视频 雅恶影院 相奸游戏泽艺 性爱互插阴交视频 新年午夜剧场 小明看看永久免费视频2 香蕉视屏 magnet 绿椅子完整版good电影 美国成人综艺节目磁力链接 瑟瑟影院大香蕉视频 日本性奴隶视频 欧美日本亚洲性爱视频图片 色色哒福利 夭夭色综合区 成人看片趣趣影院 骚女在线播 搜索午夜色色色色色和口交 xxxxxxxxx黄色 AV视频免费观i 美国啪网站福利 王者荣耀caobishipin 邪恶少3d欧美里番工 农夫AV神马枪AV神马影院 日本大妈优女性爱视频 图片视频亚洲伦理片 黄u视频 色站 在线 伦理 偷拍 韩国人妻在线影院 最新日韩av在线 怡红院分站 色琪琪影色 影音先锋 Av3847 很像杨颖的无码av 手机在线2018天堂一本道网 超漂亮美女AV mp4 六年级学生教师性交 w'w'w'x'x'x日本 新谷露影院11411 98午夜影院观看 汤姆影院htt66avtv 贵妇的沉沦女王反转版 九州视频永久地址发布 永不迷路 丝袜电影五朵美女网 0855的BT种子分享中心手机上怎么不能下载 不要按装什么视频靠开流量能看到男女做爱过程 PPPD-642 骑马乳交插乳抽插 JULIA 最后是厉害的 插美女嫩穴 超乳爆乳巨乳影片福利 Q欧美无码 sus 悠欢呀福利视频 成人福利视频手机版 成人av网站 被窝福利视频天上人间 被窝福利九州 ganyuemuyingyuan 野驴福利网址大全导航 强奸强暴真实在线视频网站 在线免费毛片基地 色凌综合 非洲操逼逼视频 6878wao FSET-532 啪啪啪视频网站上去衣图片给我看看你的照片看看你现在在哪里番acg 风流寡妇三级观看 濑亚美莉magnet 无码 54jb 久草在线2017成人免费动漫视频 在线福利gv ckplayer 资源网 SDMT-921 苍老师啪啪啪视频 夜秀live最新v视频在线播放 子宫崩坏系列番号种子 SSSxin视频 操同学妹妹第二弹粉嫩逼微醺脸红-by 海哥 男女啪啪1000粒视频 荷兰性交视频 一七六九b大香蕉在线 小哥在线国产视频 8月亚洲高清唯爱 操小姐小红屄视频 草妞视频在线观看 两只硕大的巨乳涨奶水 亚洲视频大香蕉姐妹 nanrecaobishipin 处女膜磁力链接 下载 6080伦理大尺度视频 午夜福利国产2000 深喉口交资源 无内衣揉胸吸奶视频 欧美AV黄色网站观看 HIMA-009 mp4 A天堂影院2014在线观看 五月天之色婷婷 av蓝导航 奇葩鱼在线 magnet 33KKa路Com 日本风媚娘巨乳无圣光 嘿嘿帝国视频神马 日本小女学生肛交视频中文视频 亚洲影院色妞 水中人体磁力链接 下载 日韩女优偷拍 桃色星期天 www所有强奸电影 美国一级无码aa视频 色妞ppp 美国人与兽性生活手机版 沙发上爆操白嫩小女友在线视频 六度影院最新网址 伦理片essue免费速播 伦理片2012天堂快播 亂倫片 美女操b真人直播视频 伦理片艳午秀表演 美女操逼内射视频 极品色无极影院 金荷娜17部svip视频磁力 人人摸人碰2016 情趣内衣开档福利视频 精品幼女在线视频 极品网红兼职外围女喝高了和粉丝炮友啪啪这逼嫩得没说的 下载 强奸乱伦成人小视频 家政妇波多野结衣 人妖啪啪啪视频 免费大尺度互舔视频 小清新影院体验服 四虎萝莉 很黄很细的av小说 尻女人露屄图 闺蜜双飞10p 性感视频在线 金刚狼vs神奇女侠h版 手机看片永久免费在线观看国产频道 国产在线视频发布地址 youjizz中国少女 亚洲熟妇三级黄 森萝财团视频 91波哥盛世大厦刚下班 黑人做爱插入下面视频 黄片啊啊啊啊嫩女 后入车震在线 夫妻露脸偷窥自拍 伦理伦理制服 放放动漫网在线在线acg琉璃神社 免费试看邪恶影院 涩涩禾 人体艺术伦里 911影院午夜福利 日本尻屁片 被窝影院金瓶梅 久久爱国产自拍 色琪琪伊人色综合 欧美大片h版58部合集在线观看 在线超碰天天 Sasha Grey先锋资源 久久草原在线 ftp 五月天毛片基地 小明看看大香蕉在线观看 4438咱们看不了 8888A片 毛片看看尻逼 爱情3级片网站 美女教师种子下载 mp4 92cncn 国产 AA级黄色视频 在线视频 国产 第一页 宋芝善视频在线 邪恶外国黄色网站 射在高跟鞋上的精子视频 洛天依H magnet迅雷 国产自拍视频青青草 男人射精呻吟视频 日本熟妇性交视屏 奸杀剧情里番 在线观看3D同人里番动画 泡桑拿被干的番号 8844cbcom 秋霞伧理 日韩啪啪视频无码输出 苍老师岛国片在线看 久久人人看 の五十路bd在线观看 欧美h片巨无霸 被偷拍的女主播樱木6 689aaa eee222 性虐待视频日本 xxoo视频免费欧美激烈 saolou 日本125视频jzz7 porno sayuri mikami 明星淫乱亚洲色 美女大肥阴户露阴图 678avi 人体艺术超大胆图集 野外性freexxx 少女裸替艺术网 香港三级片新江山美人影音先锋 干日本女优影音先锋 女人逼生孩子过程图片 刚肏的屄15p 幼女无码电影性爱偷拍自拍 展屄人体 新母子相奸游戏高月幸穗 外国大妈会阴照片 波多野结美图 深圳真实换妻 66电影成人电影 老外的大鸡巴插中国美女 男人人体艺术露阴茎 欧美兽交肛交群交口交双插 强奸虐屄小说 qvod插菊花网 日本欧美乱伦裸图片 小说成人母子 淫色爷爷2 幼女跟大人做爱影院 免费成人无码快播网址 青木纯奈快播 裸体骚夫